unrest, Zionist activity has become somewhat weak in Russia. The negative process of the revolution of throwing down institutions could hardly produce anything positive; and the hopes looming up on the horizon of the Russian Jews, of a secure home and humane treatment, could not but dazzle their eyes for the moment and make them blind to the more calm and serene light of a distant Zionism. But with those hopes unfulfilled and with the comparative pacification of the country, things have returned to their old channels, and Zionism pushes on its campaign in Russia with more vigor than before. It produces the greatest bulk of Zionist literature; sends forth its pioneers to reclaim the ancestral land, and gradually ousts its rival movement, Territorialism, from its strongholds.
As for the influence of Zionism on Russian Jewry, it is inestimable. It would not be to the purpose to lay a finger on this or that Jewish institution and say this is a direct Zionist creation, although numerous institutions can be pointed out as such; for this would give no idea of the real situation. For, if in most other countries, the interests of Zionism stand as yet apart from the interests of the Jewish communities, in Russia the connection between both is so close that the conquest of the communities by Zionism, a dream of Herzl, is being accomplished there not by strategy of war but by sheer identification of Zionism with the needs of the communities.
When we cross the boundary to Germany, we see a most remarkable process in the history of Zionism. The gulf stream of Jewish culture and enlightenment (Haskala) that issued from Germany at the end of the 18th century and emptied itself by the end of the 19th century into Russia, is now winding its way back toward Germany, with this important difference, that now the Jewish revival is consciously and outspokenly nationalistic. The reason for this phenomenon is, to be found, to a great extent, in the influence of the German people upon the German Jews. The Germans are a heavy race; their thinking capacity is profound, but slow. It takes them time to digest a subject, but once they grasp the truth of it, they cling to it with
tenacity, enlarge upon it, modify it and do not send it forth to the world at large until they have shaped it into a perfect thing. And this characteristic has not escaped the Jews in Germany; it has left its impress upon them too. The German Jews were by no means slow to recognize the truth of Jewish nationalism; on the contrary, they were the first to call themselves "Germans of the Mosaic faith;" their religious reform, which was aimed as a blow at Jewish nationalism, and their "protest Rabbis," have become historic. But no sooner had they digested this truth, than they surrendered to Zionism with their artists, their poets, their men of letters and science. And now not only are the German Zionists the most splendid "Landsmanschaft," having an enviable organization and contributing the most to the movement, but they have become, so to say, the brains of Zionism, laying its plans and carrying on its strategy.
Another feature of the German Zionists deserves notice. The German Zionists were in Herzl's time the most stubborn adherents of Political Zionism and the boldest denunciators of "Culture Zionism" and the immediate-activity-in-Palestine theory. Now, they are the most ardent promoters of Jewish culture—forming clubs for Jewish music, giving exhibitions of Jewish art, establishing courses of Jewish Jewish literature, and they are most vigorous and systematic workers for the immediate rehabilitation of Palestine. And these endeavors are indeed rewarded by splendid results. Jewish nationalism is gradually extending its influences over everything Jewish in Germany. Perhaps in no other country are comparatively so many Zionists without a Zionist consciousness as in German Jewry. The "Bezalel" school in Palestine thus owes its existence to the German Jews, and the Hilfsverein, which creates in Palestine such institutions as kindergartens, primary schools, teachers' seminaries, and a school of technology on a national basis and in the national spirit, is, of all non-Zionist organizations working in Palestine, such as the Alliance, the A. J. A., the only one that "understands the role that the Jews in Pales-