story of resignation and chastisement of soul. In vain will one look there for striking incidents that are out of the ordinary. In fact, the incidents as such do not provoke the interest of the reader. It is the man described that lays claim to our attention, and it is because the man described calls for sympathy, that the reader follows the hero, takes deep interest in his life and destiny, and concerns himself even with the details of his career.
His first romance, "In the Winter," which is a diary wherein he puts down all the incidents of his life, Brenner opens with this introduction: "I prepare for myself a little notebook of blank paper, and there shall write the impressions and features of my life. 'Life' in uotation marks, as there is no future or present for me; there remains only the past. The past . . . If one were to overhear this remark, he would surely think that I have to tell something terrible of my past, of some thrilling tragedy, heart-piercing and enervating.
"But this is not so; there is nothing of great interest in my past, no surprising incident, nor any appalling tragedy, nor any duel or rivalry in love, not even a big winning in a lottery or a sudden inheritance. There are, though, people-shadows, gloomy sights, choked tears, and sighs."
And still Brenner writes his romance, since it is merely meant as a diary for himself, but it is of great interest, even for us as strangers.
"In the Winter"—This name is appropriate to the situation. The cold pierces our bones. We make the acquaintance in this romance of an old generation that has forfeited its rights to existence, and of a new generation that has not strengthened its position as yet. The new generation struggles with the old, the struggle jars our nerves, but does not arouse within us any respect for the participants. The father, Melamed, is still struggling over religious questions. He wishes that his son shall be devoted to his people, a pillar of the Torah, but this desire does not spring from a source of pure religion and holy piety. And so the old generation that Brenner in-
troduces to us does not provoke gentle feelings. The surroundings of the old generation are too petty, and are crowded with a vermin people, with no ideas, and after great exertion and disquietude, we enter into a new period, are admitted into a new sphere, but there is no pleasure even there, for again we meet fierce winter with clouded skies, gloomy scenes, choked tears and sighs.
Brenner writes his second romance, "Around the Point," and despair reaches its highest pitch.
They turn around the point, turn in an enchanted circle, and cannot unravel the knot. And again we see a gathering of people disappointed in life, people that do not enjoy life in the least, and still on the dry lips there is engraved the word, "Life."
But beyond the Ghetto life it is so interesting, so worthy of its name, and it beckons: "Come, men, enjoy, everything is so natural, so normal here," . . . yet they remain where they are, moving around the point, and incessantly complain, protest and threaten, and the Jewish pale brims full with plaintive songs, with protests. Brenner draws a picture of the Jewish Ghetto in its dark burning colors with great ingenuity, and we almost hear the murmurs and protests, and we can almost feel the thickness of the despair.
Brenner fully understands the causes of this terrible state of affairs, does not become indignant, does not curse, but deep in his soul bears the grief and remains silent.
And sometimes when the drops of dissatisfaction have gathered and overflowed the boundaries, and he cannot bear it any longer, he writes his feuilletons and there he is true to himself, and free too. There he is not hampered by his objectivism, and he uses the lash liberally.
Not so with his sketches. In them he is an artist, draws a picture, forms a line and no more.
"Be silent and draw!"—There is no place for subjective feelings, curses or sighs.
And Brenner does not curse, for how can he curse "where God had already cursed."