The Maccabaean · Vol. XV, No. 3 · September 1908
122printed page
scan 16 of 44

Jewish ghetto. Unfortunates! On every side the sick man is turned he feels his pain.

. . . Very frequently one man turns from Zionist to Socialist, from Socialist to Territorialist, from extreme Idealist to a coarse Materialist, into a Cynic who believes in nothing and in no one, who laughs derisively at everything holy or divine; into an Egotist who rates everything from the standpoint of his own enjoyment. After all these metamorphoses he remains dissatisfied and an undefinable grief presses against his heart. The Egotist who, in theory, knows no bar to his will, and who considers his life superior to everything, even he does not after all perpetrate anything good or bad to improve his condition, and thus remains poor and "barefooted" all his life, dies and not one of his ambitions are realized.

The heroes of Brenner's romances sin only in their mind, in their heart, but not in reality, and the soul remains therefore in its original purity in accordance with the words of the Talmud: "The Omnipotent does not consider an evil thought an evil act." They are pessimists, those strange men, and pessimism eradicates all their good inclinations.

They despair of everything, and their only friend is the broken and shattered lounge on which they stretch themselves out, looking up to the ceiling and brooding over their gloomy thoughts. "Liberty, room and light" murmurs the Idealist who thirsts for light, recites some verses of a poet about the sun and lovely breezes, while when the bewitching sun sheds her golden light on the world, this very Idealist remains secluded in his room.

Brenner is the artist of the intelligentia par excellence. He has attempted to give a picture of the life of the average man, and in a certain sense has been successful, "In the Yard," in which he pictures an old man of the common people, and with the magic of art reveals to us his very soul, all its mysteries, simple in their complexities. Still we are within the limits of truth when we say that not in this lies his greatness. The Jewish intelligentia, with all its shortcomings and defects, is the realm of Brenner, and he really knows how to show us their life.

The intelligentia in general is given over to thinking, deliberation and hesitation. It busies itself with its own soul and it is not able to do much. It lacks the sound instinct of the masses who do things without much inquiry, discussion or analysis. The intelligentia sharpen their brains at the expense of other qualities, and in a sophistical way can allow things that are forbidden and vice-versa. The motto, "On the one hand you cannot deny the truth of it and on the other you cannot admit it," is typical of the intelligentia which decides everything on the ground of pure reason. The intelligentia cannot therefore influence things in a direct manner, and there are always symptoms of doubt and disbelief in whatever they do. And if this is the case with the intelligentia of other nations, surely it is so with the Jewish intelligentia, which lacks all the good qualities and elements that help so much to build up the character of the intelligentia of other people.

Brenner is not eloquent, his vocabulary is not rich or abundant. He does not display too many colors, but he knows how to make proper use of his words. He chooses carefully the proper expressions and carefully arranges them in the effective form. Not only does he take pains in combining words, but he is careful to use them sparingly, and he does not becloud the situation with many pompous words, for the sake of effect or beauty of expression. He goes direct to the point, and it is quite probable that the scarcity of words in his dictionary exerts a good influence on the development of his talent, for he escapes the danger of being caught in the meshes of verbosity and hollow phrases, as it is often the case with young writers.

As a realist, Brenner is consequently objective, devoted to reality, to life as it is, and still you feel that he is not merely an unconcerned spectator while writing, but, on the contrary, takes part in the misfortunes of his heroes. But since he is objective, he checks the feelings that storm within his breast. You will hear, however, the echo of a soul that is in deep distress if you are a man of soul and endowed with the gift of keen hearing.

The romances of Brenner are also a long