things" he was forced to repeat his first successes with an increasing emphasis upon the coarse and the commonplace" and further that "he followed where he had set out to lead" and that "in his last work (Ben Ami) he still adhered to the ame method that had made his reputation thirty years before"; in other words, that from all that transpired during thee thirty eventful years the introduction of culture amongst his people, the creation of a fairly passable literature and the creation of a school of real modern European writers, the admitted advance of the stage and the superiority of both the Jewish people, the theatre-going public as well as the newer playwrights and actors—of all these he has learnt nothing and benefited nothing by, and that the last and crowning effort of the matriculated graybeard is not one whit better, is the same sort of cheap drivel as the effusion of the young and new recruit of the stage. When we speak of compromises, then we shall know that we have absolutely no right to mention them in the same breath with the hero, for really great men never did compromise and attempt to overcome the antipathy of the rabble by stooping to their level; whenever any great man experienced within himself the impulse of a divine message, whenever he felt the germ of a great idea taking root in his brain, there develop and then torture him with its clamors for an outlet for conversion into a corporate fact, then he preached his ideal and worked very hard to gain converts to it. He may have made some slight concessions to the people's habits or prejudices when they were harmless and he saw the absolute necessity of that course, but he never temporized, never compromised with obscenity, vulgarity and vice, let alone stimulating it by his additions to the already well-stocked supply of that commodity. The writer also asserts "that Mr. Goldfaden was not a writer of dramas but a mere producer of farces and operettas"; very well, then, I beg leave merely to change the title of my article and to substitute the word "playwright" for that of "dramatist" and I admit that this correction and this demarcation of the real limits of the real scope of our author's abilities will indeed help matters some wee bit, for by the drama we commonly understand the higher form of composition, clear concep-
tion, a faultless construction, a pure and poetical diction and the faithful portraying and delineation of character, faithfulness to life and a well-connected, continuous narrative and not unconnected, disjointed scenes which follow one another. The drama is considered by critics as the highest form of literary executive, ranking above all other forms of narrative, even the romance and epic (see Dr. Samuel Johnson's "Lives of the Poets" and Wm. Hazlitt's "Lectures on Shakespeare"), while of the other forms of stage representation we do not expect so much of, we are quite content to do without the literary finish, without the exquisitely-wrought phrases or the melodious diction. Still we do require of it to be faithful to life; it must represent to us living, breathing, possible beings acting in the midst of ordinary circumstances and not impossible, idealized or mud-bedraggled beings, tin soldiers, wooden men, inanimate mannikins who possess no initiative, no volition of their own and we do not know at one moment what they will do in the next, for who can predict the direction in which the manipulator will pull the string? And if he did operettas, must they therefore be so flagrantly untrue to the life and the people they allege to portray?
When Richard Wagner composed his "Ring das Neibelungen," which deals with the doings of mythical Germanic and Scandinavian gods and ancient people, he was very accurate in reproducing for us the life of those beings as it was supposed to be then and the same is true of all other composers, great or small, but did our author do that? Can it be said that he was conscientious and painstaking enough to study the environment, habits and manners of the people? Did he, for instance, appreciate the incongruity of having Absalom, a prince of Judea during the first Temple, sing a song of the exile in which the Jew is described as a "tradesman and wanderer," speaks of "the widow of Zion who sits alone" and to cap the climax he speaks of an invention of the nineteenth century—railroads! Is it artistic to introduce a "Noson Ha'kohen" with a body as corpulent as a hippopotamus and who wabbles like a duck and acts, on the whole, like a madman? Or is it artistic to introduce us, in tht tragedy of Bar Kochba, to a R. Elizer Hamodoi, who behaves and
