THE MACCABAEAN
THE ESSENCE OF THE JEWISH QUESTIONS
By M. L. LILIENBLUM.
Translated by Dr. B. Levenberg
To solve the difficult problem of how to deliver the Jews from their sad condition in Eastern Europe has created many dissenting parties among Jewry. Each party advocates the adoption of its own proposed remedy. Some see salvation for the poor working class in emigration to other countries; others claim they need not seek any new fatherland, but should remain where they are, refrain from doing anything which may displease their neighbors and strive to secure equal rights, etc., etc.
Which of these proposed plans is the nearest to a solution of the Jewish question?
Some of the Jewish sociologists, the optimists, are of the opinion that the great sufferings which the Jews have endured during the Middle Ages are things of the past; they would have us believe that the modern Antisemitism, which was invented by Bismarck for his political purposes, will not last much longer, and the pogroms and massacres in the Slavice lands, which are the results of legal disabilities, will cease as son as the Jews will obtain equal rights with the rest of the population.
The optimists will come toa truer, though bitter, conclusion if they but consider that every historical event has its deep roots in the life and history of the community in which it occurs. Could Anti-semitism originate ın Western Europe, brutal pogroms and massacres occur in
Slavic countries, if the soil were not favorable to such indeals? And what makes the soil favorable?
This question is easily answered by a brief study of the causes of the sufferings of the Jews during the Middle Ages, of the comparatively tolerable condition in Poland, the emancipation of the Jews in Western Europe in the 18th century and their legal disabilities in Eastern Europe.
It is natural that a stranger should be tolerated in a family as a guest as long as he does not interfere in the affairs of the family; but should he interfere with the interests of the household, he is politely or rudely told to depart. It is the instinct of self-preservation. A whole people is but one large family, which instinctively does not suffer in its midst "strangers" who compete with its own members.
During the Middle Ages religion was the sign of distinction between "one's own" and the "stranger." The Christian was "one's own" and the non-Christian was "the stranger." But the unhappy Jew needed the means to exist no less than "the aborigines" and consequently this "stranger" to gain a livelihood must work no less than the native. And here came a collision of interests and people. The privileged members of the family did not like to see the "stranger" do the work he himself could perform; or, in other words, he hated to see the Jew compete with him. This was