The Maccabaean · Vol. XV, No. 1 · July 1908
12printed page
scan 15 of 44
Facsimile · scan 15 of 44
Scan of p. 12
Text · transcribed from the scan

to do—especially when then as now the whole trouble might have been avoided by some such small thing as using a little bit of water. Of course, the leaders were full of assurances that all would be well, but when life is at stake it takes superhuman faith to follow the nmara human

ETF “In the first place, there must have been great opposition to embarking upon this perilous journey advanced by the safe and sane friends of the Jewish people. Always there have been the conservative elements who have counselled deliberation, re-consideration, calmness, quiet, carefulness, caution — when really the most dangerous thing was to take this advice. The speeches of these advisers are not on record, but methinks they are now delivered in modern garb in the form of sermons from some of our pulpits. And when, think you, are these things spoken— on the Passover, in celebration of our birth of freedom.

“It is always easier to celebrate than to fight for freedom, but if we can do nothing but celebrate, it must be done in one way, in the spirit of those who have made the holiday. Those who would argue or do things differently have nothing to do with the festival of freedom. The issue has been fought out and the matter has been settled long ago and only those who are avowedly and unequivocally for Jewish freedom should stand up and be counted; those only should celebrate and besides celebrating they should signify their intention of doing something to make Jewish freedom a reality again. The others who stand up should be counted as a class by themselves, and the class should be properly labeled.

“The issue has been fought out a long time ago; what was then gained has since been lost, and for the present no one is asking us to plunge into any deeper sea than that of the Haggadah. All that is left us is a story, but we might at least be true to that story. We might at least remember that Jewish freedom means freedom to be Jews and not to be everything else—and to talk nonsense.

“The question has been threshed out fully. There were those among the Jews in Egypt who said we were not a nation but a re-

ligious sect and therefore we did not need any freedom; that we had a mission and it was to teach the Egyptians how to make bricks without straw. There were those others who argued that the problem of the Jews in Egypt would be solved on Egyptian soil and some of them cried out that it was unpatriotic to think of the Jews as a distinct people and to seek a country of their own. These latter called themselves Egyptian Jews and they asked: ‘Shall Egyptian Judaism give up its ideals?’ The Jews formed a big part of the population and they could get certain rights and privileges there and then. They were told that they should keep their stores closed both on their Sabbath and the other people’s Sabbath. It was a good country and the rations were excellent. Still they were not satisfied and wanted to have a country of their own wherein to work out their own kind of freedom.”

“What kind was that?” asked Mr. Zweifel.

“Well,” said Keidansky, “they had an idea that they could have freedom that was really free. On the birthday of that freedom it is hard to understand just what they meant.”

The Alliance Universelle Israelite, which supports a synagogue and school at Varna, in Bulgaria, has prohibited the holding of lectures in the school building, on the ground that Zionist lectures are being delivered there. It appears, however, that the action of the Alliance was prompted by an untrue report sent by the director, yet the school remains closed for lecture purposes. The School Committee is composed of Zionists, but, according to one report, they have been very tactful not to introduce Zionism in the lectures given under. their auspices. The attitude of the Alliance is strongly denounced, says the correspondent of the Jewish Chronicle.

The poems of Ch. N. Byalik have recently been re-issued in a handsome new edition. The volume is in large form, like an album; print and paper are excellent, and the decorative title-pages are very tastefully done. The collection of Byalik’s poems is complete, except for some early ones which have been purposely omitted.