The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 6 · June 1908
241printed page
scan 31 of 42
Facsimile · scan 31 of 42
Scan of p. 241
Text · transcribed from the scan

man should have known that to say anything on the subject was treason.

The American Hebrew was, however, guilty of an indiscretion on its own side. It should not have impressed the value of the adage about silence being golden upon Miss Richman. In diplomacy, the indiscretion of an agent is never made the subject of a public rebuke, unless it is intended that the agent shall be punished. The East Side, well versed in diplomacy by now, at once took the cue and proceeded to move the machinery of government for her removal. They went so far as to ask the representatives of the Alliance to remove her from the directorate of the Alliance.

THE MaccABAEAN believes that the petition for the removal of Miss Richman should have been based upon charges more important than those given. Any section of our citizenship has a right, political and otherwise, to ask for the removal of a public ofhicial who in action or speech injures its reputation. If it is influential enough, if the charge is serious enough, then it may, with propriety and justice to itself, demand the removal from office of the culprit.

It cannot, however, take notice of trivialities. Miss Richman's crime was no crime at all. She said what every "good" American of the Jewish persuasion has been saying, in his own circles, of the obnoxious behavior of the immigrant class. Miss Richman is guilty only of an indiscretion, and her punishment, by the rules of diplomacy, should be meted out to her as one of the directors of the Alliance, and there more may be said of her pernicious activity than elsewhere.

It is as a representative of a Jewish institution that Miss Richman should be rebuked. As Jews, we should not permit her to speak in our name, but we have nothing to do with her opinions except as they are uttered as a director of a Jewish institution. As a director of the Alliance, Miss Richman has been strenuously favorable to the rapid assimilation of the immigrants. She has been a consistent advocate of that form of Americanism which requires all our citizenship to be moulded in one form, which means the discrediting of our traditions, of our individual propensities, and of our racial pride. She has used her influence

as director of the Alliance to stifle healthy racial pride; she has sought to use the Alliance as an instrument to eradicate everything Jews should consider of value; she has spoken in favor of rending families apart in the name of assimilation. All this she has done while her position has made her utterances of significance. Patriotic sentiments of Jews belong, however, only to Zionists, who, when they speak the truth about Jews, present the defense and the remedy.

It remains for the American Hebrew to amend its "golden" rule, and to favor the removal of Miss Richman from the directorate of the Alliance.

JEHUDAH STEINBERG FUND.

Appeals are being circulated for a special fund for the support of the widow and children of the late Jehudah Steinberg, the noted Hebrew writer. Recently in New York city a benefit was given for Steinberg and two other Jewish writers. In England, Leon Simon, in a recent number of the Jewish Chronicle, makes the following statement:

"Steinberg's high rank among modern writers of Hebrew is undisputed. His Fables have become almost classical; and as a writer of stories he showed himself master of a fine narrative style, and possessed of descriptive power and a grasp of the fundamental facts of human character. It is not my business here, however, to estimate the literary value of his works. They are to appear in a new edition, which will doubtless find thousands of readers. But meanwhile Steinberg's widow and three small children are left without provision for their livelihood. A committee of the deceased writer's friends has been formed in Odessa for the purpose of obtaining support for his family; and the London Hebrew-speaking Society, "Dobrei Ibrith," have appointed a local committee here to gather such pecuniary assistance as may be forthcoming from this country. As treasurer of this committee, I appeal to your readers for a generous, if tardy, recognition of Steinberg's genius. Any donation sent to me will be acknowledged and forwarded by me to the Odessa committee, which will be responsible for handing over the money collected to the widow and orphans." Mr. Lubarsky is treasurer of the New York Committee.