tioned. The petition duly came on to be heard, and the attention of the Court being called to the very wide area over which the ordinary shareholders of the company were scattered, to the small number who had recorded their votes, and to the importance attached to the question in issue by the Jewish community, the learned Judge, after some discussion, ordered the petition to stand over until April 7 in this year, and in the meantime he directed advertisements to be inserted in a number of papers circulating amongst the Jewish race in various parts of the world, and, as I understand, he approved a form of advertisement which invited the shareholders to communicate their assent to, or dissent from, the proposed alterations. The result of the advertisements is this: Replies have been received from 18,493 shareholders, holding 59,- 543 shares, and of these 16,006 shareholders, holding 50,117 shares, support, and 2,487, holding 9,426 shares, oppose, the alteration. The resolution, therefore, is supported by a majority of five to one, or thereabouts, of those who voted, but, on the other hand, the vast major-. iy of the shareholders, representing over three-fourths of the share capital, have made no response and given no indication of their wiches.
At the hearing the petition has been vigorously opposed on behalf of the minority partly upon grounds of expediency and the like, which, in view of what I have already stated, I hold myself disentitled to consider, partly on the ground that the real opinion of the shareholders has not been and really cannot be ascertained, and partly, again, on the ground that it would be unfair and inequitable to deprive the minority once and for all of all opportunity of getting the company to exercise power which it frankly admitted must remain dormant so long as the Council remains of its present opinion in regard to them. The last two grounds of opposition very largely overlap—the minority are entitled to point to the absolute shareholders as constituting the body which is open to conviction and which is quite as likely to adopt their views as it is to adopt those of the present Council. "Either," they
say, “that body has not been reached by the advertisements, in which case the Court is deciding in the absence of over three-fourths of the shareholders, or, if it has been reached, it has shown itself so apathetic as to evidence a mind open to conviction, and in this latter alternative we ask not to be deprived of the chance of bringing about that conviction.” I think these arguments ought to prevail. The Council of the Company, by reason of the regulation as to the founders’ shares and under the trusts upon which these shares are held, have it in their power so long as they are so minded to restrict the operations of the company in the manner and to the extent in and to which they are now confined, and, being a co-operative body, the members of which are elected for their lives, if is quite possible that the extended powers of the company now dormant will never be called into activity. But, although the Court cannot, and indeed world not, wish to control this state of things, it is a very different thing where it is appealed to take a step the effect of which will be to secure its permanency , whatever be the opinion of the majority of the shareholders for the time being, and whatever be the political exigencies affecting the prosperity—possibly in some parts of the world the very existence— ofa great people. I think if I were to sanction these alterations I should be doing very little for those who advocate them and inflicting an unfair restraint—possibly an injustice— on those who oppose them, and accordingly I dismiss the petition and I order the company to pay the costs of those contributories who have appeared and opposed the petition.
The Smaller Actions Comite has decided, in view of the adverse decision of Justice Eve, to emphasize the second part of the resolution adopted by the Congress on the statutes of the Colonial Trust which reads as follows:
"The Smaller Actions Comite shall, under all circumstances, work with the aim that the Jewish Colonial Trust shall undertake colonization activities nowhere in the entire world, with the exception of Palestine, Syria and the neighboring lands."