The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 4 · April 1908
161printed page
scan 29 of 38
THE MACCABAEAN
161

THE MACCABAEAN

Published once every month by the Maccabaean Publishing Company, of which M. B. Lande is President; and D. H. Lieberman is Secretary; whose address is 547 Broadway, New York City. Edited by Louis Lipsky.

APRIL, 1908

THE KNIGHTS OF ZION.

In reply to a correspondent, THE MACCABAEAN said, a few months ago, that the Knights of Zion was not antagonistic to the Federation; that it is a sub-Federation; that it sends delegates to our Conventions, and pays its per capita tax to the Federation.

This statement is contradicted by a number of authorities, well qualified to speak on the matter. Several correspondents from Chicago have protested against the statement made by THE MACCABAEAN, and one of them offers evidence to show that the Knights are zealously working against the organization by adopting a contrary view with relation to the alteration of the statutes of the Jewish Colonial Trust.

What the actual relation of the Knights of Zion to the Federation may be, is not so easily determined. THE MACCABAEAN knew that the Knights had defaulted in their pledges several times, that they had promised to pay their per capita tax, and had neglected to do so; that within the Knights there was a clique, who sought to create in Chicago a sub-Federation, and that this clique had been guilty of gross violations of their contracts. But legally, the Knights were, we thought, still affiliated with the Federation.

By its own dilatoriness, the Federation has made possible this confusion. It has permitted the Knights to be reinstated several times after ultimatums had been issued. It has been too careful not to create a public discussion of the difficulty. And THE MACCABAEAN, when questioned on the subject, was bound to state the legal, or formal side of the situation.

THE MACCABAEAN believes that the cause

of Zionism will be advanced by the complete breaking up of the Knights of Zion. The Knights have hampered our work; have by their incapacity and petty jealousies, retarded the growth of societies, and usurped a position, which abler and more conscientious Zionists are ready to occupy. They have broken promises solemnly made and made new promises with the intention of breaking them. They have in a number of instances acted as if loyalty to the Basle program were incidental to the existence of their organization.

They have, in short, forfeited every right to consideration at the hands of the Federation, and the Federation would be in line with its duty if it, without equivocation, declared the Knights outlawed.

DR. PAUL NATHAN'S VIEWS :

Owing to pressure on our space last month, we were unable to present Dr. Nathan’s complete views on the Palestine situation. As was expected, the interview with him cabled to this country by the Associated Press, was a garbled condensation of what he had actually said. No one in his right senses would deny that Palestine at the present time is not a favorable locality for a mass-emigration, but that there is a great deal of preparatory work to be done, which, in the course of years, will make Palestine a desirable exit out of the Goluth, is becoming more and more generally admitted, and Dr. Nathan, who pleads for high schools in Palestine, who sees a number of opportunities for the upbuilding of the country, must be included among those who have hopes for Palestine, who do not believe that the Holy Land is a dreary waste of land, which no human hand will ever fill with the spirit of life.

As we have pointed out once before, the Hilfsverein, of which Dr. Nathan is the head, and which, presumably, endorses his views, is to be reckoned with in the work, which Dr. Nathan believes possible in Palestine. Zionists will not find the Hilfsverein in line with the assimilatory Jewish organizations working in Palestine, with