The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 4 · April 1908
153printed page
scan 21 of 38
THE MACCABAEAN
153

MR. ABBOTT ON THE JEWISH QUESTION

An interview appeared in a recent number of the Jewish Chronicle on "The Jewish Question," in which Mr. G. F. Abbott, author of "Israel in Europe," gave his views on the subject, which he considered in his work with a great deal of perspicacity. In the course of this interview he said:

"What is the cause of the friction between the Jew and the Gentile in the past? I find that the main cause has been that the Jew is determined to remain a Jew. That is the main cause. People talk about economical and other reasons, but they are quite secondary. Now, that which was the main cause in the past remains the same today, and will continue to persist for many centuries; perhaps forever, if one can use such a big word.

"In the past we found, age after age, a number of Jews allowing themselves, under favorable circumstances, to be assimilated to, and absorbed in, their environment. These Jews solved the problem for themselves. Such assimilation may have been due to the wish to avoid persecution, or to social ambition, or to the desire of financial advantage. In most cases, however, voluntary absorption must, I think, be attributed to the egoism of the apostate—an egoism which overshadows all other considerations. But the majority of Jews have never belonged to that type. They were neither cowards yielding to pressure, nor self-seeking creatures who thought of their personal advantages, nor egoists, but they were men and women with whom the social instinct prevailed over their individualism.

"Now, Spinoza was a great egoist, but an egoist in the noblest sense of the term. He was an intellectual egoist—an uncompromising egoist who would sacrifice everything to what he considered to be the interests of truth, The rabbis of Amsterdam, who tried to induce him to hold his tongue, represented the other type—that of uncompromising communalists or patriots. They were not so intolerant or narrow-minded as people suppose. They would have allowed him to think what he liked, to be as great a heretic as he pleased,

so long as he remained in the syangogue. So, in the Spinoza incident we see the struggle among Jews between the two attitudes of thought—the egoistic and the patriotic.

"Coming down to the present day, we find the same attitudes still prevailing, and in more or less the same proportions, as in the past. Some Jews, from one motive or another, yield to their environment, but the majority—as in the past—prefer to face not only social ostracism, but expulsion from their homes and the loss of everything that people value, to face death itself rather than give up their separatism. So the Jew has not changed, and neither has the Gentile. Separatism in the past has always provoked the Gentile's resentment; and that resentment expressed itself in more or less barbarous fashions, according to the conditions of the particular country and age in which the Jew lived. In some cases, and in the most barbarous countries, the Jews were assailed with the sword, and the same thing is happening at the present day. In civilized countries Jews suffer from social ostracism, literary attacks, or unfair legislative measures; in more barbarous countries, like Russia, they are still liable to attacks of the sword. Hence, so far as the actual present and the immediate future are concerned, I should say that the causes of anti-Semitism are the same that they ever were, and the consequences must be the same.

"I would say that most people, to my mind, make the mistake of seeking for a solution of the Jewish Question, and do not recognize the possibility of several solutions. Everybody would admit that there are Jews and Jews; also that there are Gentiles and Gentiles. And yet, when it comes to seeking for a solution of the difficulty that arises between Jews and Gentiles, they ignore this elementary fact. Inasmuch as there are many varieties of Jews and many varieties of Gentiles, the antagonism between the two also varies. Hence there are many different Jewish questions, for which we need as many solutions.

"First, there is the extreme liberal Jew,