The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 3 · March 1908
99printed page
scan 19 of 46
Facsimile · scan 19 of 46
Scan of p. 99
Text · transcribed from the scan

paid to unearth in court (and of which the late master of the Rolls in England, Sir George Jessel said: “The use of technicalities is to defeat justice”) were brought down into the schoolroom for the delectation and the instruction of our young charges. It would be quite in vain to deny that the result of such a strenuous use of dialectics must often have been injurious, and that in some cases it may often have preverted the mind with much that was mischievously futile. But the child was taught to think, to reflect, and to know the reason why when that reason was found. Here again the ready and quick intelligence with which the outside world is always eager to equip the Jew, is the result of the training which his forbears got in these schools of the wise.

In the third place it must be remembered that the teaching in the Jewish schools was not only the exercise of the memory, the sharpening of the wit. It was not the empty discussion of a theory; it had a most distinct relation to life; in fact, it was largely the actual life that the scholar had to lead as pupil and as man that was discussed there.

Josephus, in his treatise against Apion, has dwelt upon this point and his words are of interest to us even to-day. He says: “There are two ways of getting at any sort of learning and the moral conduct of life; the one by instruction in words, the other by practical exercises. Now, other lawgivers have separated these two ways in their opinions and have chosen one of those ways of instruction, or that which best pleased every one of them, neglecting the other. Thus the Lacedemonians and the Cretans teach by practical exercises, but not by words; while the Athenians, and almost all the other Grecians; made laws about what was to be done or left vndone but had no regard to the exercising of them thereof in practice. But our legislator very carefully joined these two methods of instruction together; for he would not leave these practical exercises to go on without verbal instruction nor did he permit the word of the law to proceed without the exercises for practice.”

One would like to know more about the men who presided over such instruction. That

the standard was high one can hardly doubt. For that we have the dietum of Hillel: “Woe to him that .is occupied with the Torah and has no fear of God.” It was the greatest distinction for a teacher to exercise his profession and to receive no monetary reward. We are all acquainted with the saying of the Pharisaes: “Make not the words of the Torah a crown to glory in, nor an axe to live by;” and in another Talmudic passage God is represented as saying: “As I have taught you without hope, so must ye do likewise. It is very probable that in most cases this remained a pious wish; for not every teacher was in a position to follow the ideal; but we have abundant evidence that many great teachers of the law did not scruple to earn their livelilhood in some one of the humblest occupations. There was no shame-faced pride in this action; it sprang from the respect with which they consecrated labor and from the high ideal they had of the functions of the teacher. One of the greatest of the Rabbis, Hillel the elder, was an ordinary woodchopper; his opponent, Shammai, was a builder. Rabbi Joshua, even when elected President of the Sanhedrin, was a blacksmith. A fourth Rabbi was a tanner and a fifth nothing more than a laundryman. There were Rabbis learned in the law and respected teachers who in ordinary life were shoemakers or water carriers, sandel makers or carpenters.

A certain portion of the day or a definite time of the year was given up to the material side of life—the rest belonged to the study of the law; and the teachers advised their pupils to follow their example. “I pray ye do not come to me in the days of Siwan (harvest time) nor in the days of Tishri (viticulture time), that ye may provide for your’ maintenance during the whole year” is the counsel given by Rabha to his students. This was a fine emphasis laid upon the democratic character of the polity which these Rabbis endeavored to build up upon the ruins of the priestly aristocracy of the second temple and the princely oligarchy of the Herodian dynasty.

There was indeed need of such a democratic spirit in the troublous times that followed

425896