The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 3 · March 1908
96printed page
scan 16 of 46
Facsimile · scan 16 of 46
Scan of p. 96
Text · transcribed from the scan

tion of this love as it threatens the destruction of so much of the old. It is characteristic of this valuation, that the Talmudists read into the Bible text their own ideas on the subject. “And thou shalt teach them diligently unto thy children, when thou sittest in thine house and when thou walkest by the way, when thou liest down and when thou risest up,” was made more weighty by interpreting “Thy children” to mean “Thy disciples.” In the ninetieth psalm the expression, “Oh Lord, thou hast been our refuge in all generations” was paraphrased by a doctor of the fourth century into “Thou hast been our refuge in the synagogues and in the schools.” The writer of the second part of Isaiah had said, “Seek ye the Lord while He may be found”; and a rabbi in the third century explained to the curious that He would be found in the synagogues and in the schools. With the waning of the political importance of the second commonwealth, the life of the people concentrated in and around the schools. The reward of godliness and goodness were now seldom to be found in the outward expression of the corporate existence of the people. The wise men turned to a more intense study of that godliness, and almost lost themselves— not as mediæval monks did, in the ecstatic contemplation of an ideal—but in the study of the Divine will as applied to the minutest details of every day life. “Get for thyself many pupils,” is one of the behests of the Pharaseean fathers of the synagogue; and to this they added “procure for thyself a teacher and acquire a companion in study.” Innumerable are the sayings that might be quoted in which this feeling of the necessity and the majesty of study finds expression. “By the truth from the mouth of school children the world is sustained” may indeed be a hyperbole of the oriental kind; but it well represents the underlying feeling of these men. The story of Jochanan ben Zakkai is already trite, even before a Jewish audience. By establishing a school of the law in Jamnia, he undoubtedly did much to save Judaism for coming generations. It is not to detract from his merit, nor from the merit of so many of his fellow rabbis, to imagine that this reverence for study was perhaps carried be-

yond the limits of what was necessary and useful. The times were stirring and the whole energy of the people was needed in the very practical work of warding off the overwhelming hand of the Roman power. It is true that many of the rabbis took a noble part in the defense of their country; perhaps it would have served the ultimate purpose better if more of them had done so and if practical statesmen had been at the helm instead of contemplative scholars.

It is during this time of the second commonwealth that we first hear of regular and systematic instruction being given to the young. Josephus, the historian, was able to say in the noble polemic which he waged against the detractors of his people in Alexandria: “We busy ourselves with the education of the young more than with anything else, Ask the first one you may meet concerning our laws, he will recite their tenor more readily than he will tell his own name. As we study the laws from the moment when our conscience awakens, they are, so to say, engraven upon our souls” That Josephus, in his ardor, was not going beyond the bounds of truth, is shown by the most interesting tradition handed down in the name of Rabh, a foremost Babylonian teacher. He says: “At first every father himself instructed his son; the orphan, however, remained untaught. At a later time the order was given to establish schools at Jerusalem, to which even the children from the provinces had to be brought. Still later, each district had its school; but the children came there when already sixteen or seventeen years of age, and they rebelled when the teacher became severe, and remained at home. At last, Joshua ben Gamla laid down a law that instructors were to be appointed in every place of the country, and he obligated children when six or seven years of age to go to school.” We have here, I think, one of the earliest instances of compulsory education. The history and character of this tradition has indeed been doubted. Joshua ben Gamla lived in the first century of our era and during a time which certainly was not propitious for such enactments. Bacher sup: poses that it was his namesake, Joshua ben