The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 1 · January 1908
4printed page
scan 8 of 46
4
THE MACCABAEAN

have we that the change, if it come about, will be firm and lasting?

These questions demand an answer, not in words, but in deeds. Verbal answers we have given times without number. There is only one way, we have said, to change the conditions of our national life fundamentally, so that it shall become our life indeed, and not a passing shadow of the life of other people; and that way is the foundation of a centre for our national spirit in the place of its birth. Further, we have promised more than once that this way of ours, like every new path, will be made and prepared by the few for the many, who will afterwards follow of their own accord. But when we came to turn our words into deeds, it became clear that chaos and black night still hold sway in the depths of our spirit, in spite of the light of conviction that plays on the surface.1

Whoever knows by experience how dear the Holy Land is still to every plain Jew, how his heart swells—sometimes even to the point of joyful tears—when he reads or hears of the revival of the Hebrew language among the children in Palestine, or of the success of the Hebrew colonies there—whoever knows this cannot deny that the actual work of building up a centre in Palestine, even before it approached its goal, could have had a wonderful influence on the spirit of the people in the lands of our exile. The truth is, that even now the majority of our people cherish their national inheritance, and desire its eternal preservation; but the servitude of Galuth, material and spiritual, cramps the heart, and renders the national feeling and will incapable of .becoming an active working force. And yet, if our work in Palestine had been such as to show clearly that there is really a prospect and a fair hope for the life of our spirit and our national possessions in the land of their birth; if the people had seen the foundations of the building laid by expert hands, one complete stone upon another, though the stones had been but small: then the people would have sought and found here a new source of life for its dormant national feelings, and the people’s

'An illusion to a metaphor developed in the first part of the article, not here reproduced.

will would have gained strength to protect its spiritual possessions in exile.

u ee dee But as things are, how can we prove the correctness of our answer? What are the results of our twenty years and more of work in Palestine? With regard to material work, we have only unsuccessful attempts to show; and as for spiritual work, we cannot even show such attempts (except, perhaps, the school at Jaffa), for in fact scarcely anything has been done. Those who desired the “ingathering of the scattered people” have labored all these years, first of all in founding philanthropic colonies, and then in political talk; they have had neither the time nor the will to meddle in spiritual matters. Those again who desired the "revival of the spirit” have also dissipated their time and their strength in spiritual work in the lands of exile: in all this time they have not created in Palestine one single literary product that has found an echo in the nation’s heart. It is as though they had forgotten the first principle of their own faith, that the revival of the spirit in exile can only come about through the influence of a national centre in Palestine. They have, indeed, said a great deal about the need for founding universities and schools. and other such needs, the satisfaction of which is beyond their power at present. But they have nut done that which was hotlhı necessary and possible.

Here, for example, is an attempt to found a small literary organ in Palestine. I ask myself: Why was this not done long ago? In the lands of exile a large number of literary plants have bloomed and faded during the Zionist epoch; and little by little they nave borne fruit, and have had a good effect, whether great or small. In Palestine, meanwhile, since the beginning of the movement there has not been published a single literary work whose effect on our literature has been noticeable. Yet we did not feel that something was lacking. We constantly told the. people that only in Palestine could our national spirit flourish and produce fruit after its kind; yet at the same time we were not ashamed to think that the people did not see in Palestine even a shadow of the fruit of its spirit, and that the little fruit that did grow was growing in other countries. It is true that Palestine is