that there are such and such a number of shekel-payers. Before that he did not know it.
He will learn something else. The people who went to hear Shmaryahu Lewen's speeches did not go on account of Zionism, but in order to see a real live member of the Duma. It is likewise possible that some went because at home the floor was being washed on that particular night. . . . Nor is it all unlikely that a few couples made the mass-meeting a convenient rendezvous. Should Dr. Fishberg make the latter claim, we could not prove it to be false.
To discover the motives actuating those who attend mass-meetings is too slippery an affair. This appears also to have been discovered by the diagnostician of the American Jews, and therefore statistics, which he uses in this connection, are very defective. There is an absence of data as to what perrentage came to the meetings to see Mr. Schiff, how many to see Mr. Lewin, how many to hear him, and how many because the weather was pleasant, etc. Only that which concerns bookkeeping is exact. If we should be in straights and offer Zionism at the pawnbroker’s, we would then know how much we can “raise.” An American told me that two of his countrymen were one day taking a stroll on the avenue of an American city. One of them noticed an old and apparently suffering and poor old man. He was deeply touched and he said: “A dreadful sight! How I pity him!” Whereupon his companion said: “But how much do you pity him?” By way of answer the former took a dollar from his purse and said: “I pity him one dollar’s worth,” and gave the poor man the coin.
Dr. Fishberg applies this method to Zionism.
It is called American, yet I believe that it is only a certain degenerate Americanism, somewhat of a pedlar Americanism; at best, commercial Americanism. In this fashion stockbrokers, pawnbrokers, and even marriage brokers, size up the value of individıals and communities. I have grave doubts whether such a measure ought to be applied to national movements. But after Dr. Fishberg has established the financial criterion as the
most decisive factor in the fortunes of the Jewish people, it will be well if he continues in the same strain. Here with the money bags! Ye Moseses and Joshuas, ye Isüiahs and Jeremiahs, ye Ezras and Maccabees, ye Bar Kochbas and Yehuda Halevis. We must count you and examine your pockets! Are you worth much? I am afraid that a moderately rich American tailor has more. Are you at least numerous? I am afraid that a second-rate athlete could carry all of them on his shoulders. How strong the founders of the second Jewish commonwealth were, we can gather with some degree of accuracy from the books of Ezra and Nehemiah. Prof. Friedrich Delitzsch showed in his lecture, which he lately delivered in Berlin, that the large majority of the people stayed behind in exile. But their numerical strength—Dr. Fishberg might perhaps calculate.e And while he is engaged in this work of calculation, he might also figure out the number of the first Christians, how large was the capital of humanism, of the Reformation or of the first American pioneers. An exact: accounting would elicit from the lips of the strict treasurer the terrible word Dalles. All of these historical, cultural and national movements, in their beginnings, possessed such small groups of followers, and were so poor, that a modern American accustomed to monster mass-meetings and 42-story sky-scrapers, and who 'hears of the billions of Standard Oil, will ignore them with contemptuous ridicule. Aye, the smallest trust is worth more; and as for masses of men, more congregate on a Sunday at any New York theatre.
I know a certain book in which it is proved, on six octavo pages, that money is a necessary commodity. Among us no one doubts this fact, and it would therefore be a waste of time, under these circumstances, to show that Zionism needs ever so many shekels and a large party fund. That is our own private affair. For certain .practical purposes, Zionism nceds more and will also have to find the means to get more. But to appraise Zionism, the self-consciousness, the renaissance, the historical tradition, the struggle for the freedom of a nation, on the basis of figures, reminds me of the Lithuanian-Jewish humorist,