cause when it is threatened with any danger, say in Venezuela, China, Turkey, the entire mechanism of all the Governments is disturbed, independent ef the nationality of the capital. The intern guarantee, created by inner social relations, cannot be given either by a charter or by concessions. This internal guarantee depends on ourselves, and is possible as the result of a long historical process. At present we must content ourselves with objective guarantees to the capital interested in the concessions and the interest of Turkey in our economic development, which will benefit her, too. Besides this, Turkey herself will not remain forever in a petrified state; there is no doubt that there, too, life must make forward strides, creating new Social, economic forms of existence and new developments. There, too, the general progress must accomplish its work. The more Europe is progressing, the more intensive becomes life in the neighboring lands, the sooner will the Ottoman Empire be regenerated and the more advantageous conditions will be created for the futrre inhabitants of Palestine.
Finally, let it be permitted to us once to appeal to sentiment, although this is not in our habit. If it is necessary to suffer, then, according to our own deep conviction, the Jewish people will prefer to suffer in its own country, where it at least will begin an economically normal life, where it can live with an assurance that the day will arrive when they will come into possession of their own fatherland, than in the lands of the Goluth, where they will always remain alien. Freedom is not obtained by purchase or charters, but earned by long labor and struggle. Our sufferings in the Diaspora in the best of circumstances only ameliorates our condition. but never will solve the fundamental problem. The blood shed by us in the Diaspora serves as a “lubricating oil” to the wheels of the stranger’s revolution; our struggles here only make it easier for a certain part of Jewry to enter the camps of other people. Sufferings and struggles on our own land will strengthen our people, and the blood shed will enrich our own life. If’'it is to be a “ubricating oil,” then let it be for our own selves, and not for others; the strife and
struggles on our own land will bring forth Jewish Maccabaeans. Here the struggle leads to division; there to integrity of the individual as well as of the whole people. Here we lose three-fourths of the people's energy in the internal strife between different parties, not caused by class interests, but exclusively by national cultural interests; there the strife will continue, but it will be concentrated on two objects: class controversies and the attainment of liberty.
"Yes," they say, "the struggle there is more difficult!" Hardly. At any rate, there the result will be happiness of a whole people; here the right to a complete and easy assimilation. For us, and for all those to whom the national regeneration of our people is dear, there is no choice. That is why we say the method of concessions does not at all exclude guarantees, but in general we do not believe in happiness without sacrifices; we do not believe in liberty obtained in the office of Chamberlain. Freedom must be secured through sufferings. The Jewish people do not fear sufferings. Moreover, there is no fatherland, for the happiness of our own people.
The last and the strongest argument which is used against us, with an air of superiority: "Do you want to outwit Turkey? Do you want to reassure it with concessions, as if Turkey does not understand that your intentions are the realization of the Basel program. How naïve you must be! If Turkey refused Herzl a charter, it will refuse you concessions!" And many questions and repeated the same arguments, not troubling to study them or to verify them by the facts of actual conditions of life!
It is known to every one that the Turkish Government, having refused Herzl a charter, offered him something else corresponding to the demands of the Basel program, yet sufficient for a beginning of work. Herzl did not accept the offer, but the fact remains that Turkey, fully aware of the aim and tendency of Zionism, did not assume a hostile attitude to Zionism. To all the wiseacres who are so intimate with the-
