CHARTER OR CONCESSION
By DR. D. PASMANIK.
(Concluded.)
IV
The concession method is subjected to criticism. We will examine all the objections against our propositions and endeavor to disprove them.
It is with great regret that we must point out the existing reliance upon authority. The greatest authority of the Zionists, our deceased leader, Herzl, was the originator of the charter idea as the only object of the Organization. This veneration of the authority of Herzi is pronounced not only among the bourgeois, but also among the foremost leaders of the Jewish proletariat, not even excluding the S. S. This is one of the most interesting incidents of our movement, but to vur regret we cannot consider it here. We assert that the followers of Herzl did not analyze things properly, namely, that the weakness of Herzl’s theory is not in its substance, but in its form. Herzl never had in view a charter, forcibly thrust upon Turkey by the European Powers and guaranteed by them, but only concessions, secured from the Turkish Government, and incorrectiy called “charter.”
Herzl expresses this idea of concessions in his novel, "Altneuland," through one of the main heroes, Joseph Levy, who says: "Our company was formed under the name, 'The New Company for the Colonization of Palestine.' This company made a treaty with the Turkish Government to people Palestine under the Sovereignty of the Sultan." Here Herzl expressed the idea of a treaty, not guaranteed by anyone, i.e., a concession and not a charter. Whoever reads attentively the speech of Herzl at the opening of the sixth Zionist Congress will agree that everything in this speech pertains not to a guaranteed charter, but to concessions granted by the
Sultan. Herzl endeavored to obtain something quite substantial from the Turkish Government, but at the same time to engage in diplomatic activities among the interested Powers; whether this was right or wrong is a different question, but the substance remains the same—concession. For Herzl, not the procurement of a guaranteed charter, but the concession, involving all the spheres of Jewish life, was of vital importance. In a speech at the meeting held in London (June 26, 1899) Herzl expressed his conception of public legal rights as follows:
"And now we will consider the third point—legal guarantees. Is it not of a greater advantage to provide ourselves with the rights of construction? How should this be brought about? If circumstances do not permit the attainment of a direct and immediate possession of a constructive plan, then there can be established a lease or vassalage (eine Pachtung order eine Lehnverhältniss). Here in England you have such legal conditions, very little known on the Continent. Such legal relations in a political sense I would want, and I hope I will realize them with the Turkish Government."
The difference between our plan and that of Herzl lies in the fact that he did not recognize any process of evolution in concessions and he wanted to obtain all at once, but we assert that this is impossible and even dangerous. The concessions must correspond to the actual forces of our people. Herzl strived to secure concessions with large privileges, which can be achieved under certain circumstances without the interference of thegreat Powers; it is sufhicient, if these Powers do not interfere at all, or, what would be better, if they will keep toward us what is called in diplomatic language “a favorableneutrality.”
Since it is the substance and not the form
