The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 6 · December 1907
265printed page
scan 39 of 52
THE MACABAEAN.
265

PROFESSOR GIDDINGS ON THE AMERICAN JEW.

In the course of popular lectures which are being given at Cooper Union, Professor Franklin H. Giddings, of Columbia University, gave a scholarly and interesting address Tuesday evening, December 3, on "The Jew in America."

Professor Giddings first outlined the different groups of Jews who had come to America since colonial times, their characteristics and their differences, the Spanish and Portuguese Jews, the German Jews, the Polish Jews, and finally the Russian Jews. Concerning the fact of the different characteristics, Professor Giddings went into the question of the purity of the racial stock of the Jew. If the records of the Bible could be considered true, the Jew of history was one of the most blended of races, "a wonderful blend of races, nearly every one of which were in some way gifted." As for later racial history in the Diaspora, it was difficult and almost impossible to speak authoritatively, so meagre was the testimony and so diverse the scholarly opinion on the subject. Yet he implied that he considered Darmstadter's opinion exaggerated with the Jew in every country became mixed with the national stock, not through his own conversion, but through converts to his religion.

"The question arises," Prof. Giddings said, "will the Jew become lost in American life as it is perfectly certain other nationalities will. . . . The Jew says, No. And I think this answer is in the main true. Because of his adherence to his religion, the Jew will be slow to intermarry with other elements. On the other hand, there is no doubt that under the freedom in this land increasing numbers of Jews are slipping away from their faith. And to some extent, I would say, the Jews, in time, though it will take longer than other nationalities, will become lost in the national blood. It will only be a slower process. To a greater extent than others he will persist as a racial element, but I think that he will find himself more acted upon, molded and absorbed by the free spirit of this land in a few generations than he was for one thousand years in Europe. Greene, of the North End.

When you put men under compression and persecution they draw in upon themselves and become a type, but give them freedom of thought and action and they cannot help cease to become a peculiar type. And in this mingling, whatever he may have been in the past, in Jerusalem or in the Old World ghettoes, the Jew will become an individual, he will take on the color of his environment, and in this land of opportunity he will first of all become a human being and after that a Jew to any extent he may wish to be."

A question was put Prof. Giddings after his lecture whether he thought the movement against Christian exercises from the schools justiied. “Every movement is justihed in America,” he said. “If we can’t have free speech, free aggression, free co-operation to bring about anything any group believes in, then we haven’t yet achieved the ideal of American civilization. I don’t see how any person can subscribe to the doctrine that it is right to tax one group of taxpayers for a general purpose and compel those taxpayers under the law to submit to things not necessary ta public peace or morals, but against his conscience I believe we should have absolute religious liberty in this land and that such practices in public schools as are acceptable to all common sense men and no others.”

BOSTON DAUGHTERS OF ZION.

The Boston Daughters of Zion gave a Thanksgiving party to the children of the Theodore Herzl Religious School, conducted by the above society, and their friends. The party was held in the hall at the Baldwin Place Synagogue and about 700 children of the North End attended. Mr. Heller, president of the Baldwin Place Synagogue, spoke to the children, after which followed some music and recitations by the children of the school, The Boston Daughters of Zion and their friends were very well pleasea with the success of this undertaking. Those who worked for the party and its success were Mr. Albert Hurwitz, superintendent of the Theodore Herzl Religious School, the school teachers and some of their friends. Notable among those who aided the Boston Daughters of Zion was Mrs.