The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 6 · December 1907
252printed page
scan 26 of 52
252
THE MACCABAEAN.

no further than the first three rows of seats in his own temple. The great world of Jewry is an unknown country, which he hopes and trusts he shall never be asked to visit. It suffices for him if he can use the influence of his paper to keep his name in type, and to impress his congregation with the power of the press. He is not averse to stealing matter from whatever source he has at hand, and usually his exchanges are sufficient for his needs. To pay for articles is contrary to the idea of his mission. Masked by the editorial “we,” he prowls about like a thief, using the scissors as a pickpocket uses his fingers. The more enterprising papers may spend their money for special correspondence, for special articles, for stories; but that does not trouble him; he appropriates, and probably will continue to appropriate to the end of his days, salving his consciemce occasionally by transferring the property rights in the articles he steals to the omniscient “exchange.” Should he, by accident of fortune come into possession of an article which has never before seen the light of day. and should an “esteemed” contemporary steal it from him, his anger knows no bounds, and an abject apology on bended knees, in scare-head type, is the only thing that will satisfy the iniury.

A few years ago, the Federation saw a letter from Palestine in one of these pirate sheets—not edited by a rabbi, but by an enter- nrising advertising agent. The letter was inte-esting, but had not been edited; names were mis-spelled, and the sentences were garbled; the Federation had the letter re-written and sent out to all the Jewish papers. A good Jewish weekly published in Baltimore, used the letter, and according to its custom, gave the Federation credit for it. The howl raised by the pirate sheet was heard from New Or- ‚ans to Boston; an apology was first demanded of the Baltimore paper; letters were written right and left, until the explanation, which did not appease anger, was sent by the responsible party. This same weekly had for years stolen, with or without credit, for it does not matter, stories and articles as if there were no moral law aside from the copyright law.

Then, the complaint is made that there are no Jewish journalists in this country. Is it

possible for a man to devote himself to Jewish journalism as a career, if all his matter is subjected to the law of the scissor, and if the paper that does pay him is not protected unless it takes the precaution of copyrighting every article in its issue? A man writing for a press bureau obtains syndicate rates; a Jewish journalist writes for a syndicate, but receives only the rates of one paper.

With the advertising agent turned publisher, we have nothing to do. They are, as a class, capable of only the lowest form of intelligence. But those journals edited by rabbis are amenable to public criticism and rebuke. The rabbi-business man is not an unknown figure in Jewish life; but when he goes into business we have a right to expect from him at least respect for the property rights of other people, and when he fills up his paper at the expense of other journals, he is doubly censurable. It is the duty of those few publications that abide by the ordinary rules of Journalism, to expose and openly condemn the pirate rabbi-editors, and protest whenever the property stolen is theirs.

THE MACCABAEAN has seen its stories clipped and republished by these pirates, month after month. And so stupid have some of them been, that stories reprinted by request, have often been stolen twice by the same papers, without a glimmer of memory as to their previous larcenies. We take this opportunity to protest. The stories and articles in this paper, not given out by their authors for general publication, are by right of ownership, ours Whoever reprints them, even with credit, has taken something from us, against our wishes, and without compensation. The copyright law cannot overrule the moral law. A thief who purloins a coat does not atone for his sin by proclaiming the name of the owner of the coat.

THE MACCABAEAN SPIRIT.

To us the Maccabaeans symbolize not only the spirit of political revolt, but also the larger virtue, that of asserting the right to one's own individuality. The Maccabaeans fought not only for release from governmental subjection, but also for the destruction of the Egreek influence in Jewish life. The victory at Emmeaus was as well a menace to Hellenized