The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 6 · December 1907
251printed page
scan 25 of 52
Facsimile · scan 25 of 52
Scan of p. 251
Text · transcribed from the scan

and local or petty prejudice have been kept alive at the flame of true Zionist enthusiasm until that flame itself has dwindled and been extinguished, in many cases. It has been impossible, also, to obtain correct information of activities, meetings have been held in a haphazard, conflicting manner, and the societies have looked to the Federation only for such assistance as they saw fit to demand, never for one moment giving the Federation the privilege of forming a general line of activity. As a consequence of this disorder the organized Zionists of New York represent, we venture to say, an insignificant minority of the Zionists of the metropolis, and there are hundreds of good Zionists who are not members of any organization.

This deplorable state of affairs, for which no One man nor any one society is responsible, least of all the Federation or the Council, has led to the appointment by the secretary of a Central Committee of Five, into whose hands has been given over the proper reorganization of New York Zionism. The appointment of such a committee, necessarily a committee of action, and not of legislation, is a regrettable necessity, but in times of danger, martial law is in order, and rigorous measures are imperative, although the principles of democracy are thus, for the time being, set aside. It would have been much better if no such committee were necessary, but this is the penalty that must be paid for previous sins of omission.

The Central Committee, however, will not be able to do much if it will not receive the loyal support of all those who are, in fact, if not legally, the leaders of the movement in New York. Their work will fail, if these leaders de not support them in a manner worthy of faithful advocates of our program. The Central Committee must have a body of men and women behind it, who will take orders in no grudging, or jealous spirit; persons who will find a satisfaction in knowing that what they are asked to do is indeed work that will build up the cause in New York, and who will stand by pledges, keep faith, be sincere in their efforts to help the organization. Men will be required to strengthen societies by their presence and co-operation ; other men will be needed, who will put themselves at the command of the Committee for a certain number of ad-

dresses each month ; other men will be asked to perform specific work, and our younger men will be asked to aid in creating that esprit de corps, without which an organization must languish. In New York, Zionism ought to work in scattered relays, but with a deliberate subdivision of work, and a readiness to transfer certain enterprises to other active Zionists, if it is known that they will do the work better and mara effertivelv.

In other words, the Central Committee hopes to establish an organization, first of all, of minute men, who will respond to the call at a moment's notice; aiding these minute men there will be a larger body of men and women who can serve only at stated intervals, but of them too faithfulness, promptness, enthusiasm, will be demanded; and beyond this second circle, we hope to have a variety of ancillary groups who will act as the supporters and the executive officers of any enterprise set in motion by the minute-men, the other leaders or by the Central Committee itself.

If such a movement of internal regeneration can be maintained for this winter, it is hoped that the necessity that brought the Central Committee into existence will have passed away, and in its stead we shall have a Zionist organization in New York worthy of our opportunities.

THE STRENGTH OF THE AMERICAN JEWISH PRESS.

THE American Jewish press is represented by about thirty weekly publications. Eliminating four or five of them, situated in the large cities of the east, they present a spectacle of weakness, ignorance and pettiness unequaled, we believe, anywhere in the world. In a number of instances, the editors are rabbis, who bolster up their popularity with a continual harping on the one string of their own virtues and renown. Of those periodicals not edited by rabbis, you will find an advertising agent, who, on the strength of representing the Jewish people, is able to maintain his advertising business. But in all cases, the amount of original matter is limited to the social columns, which are the main feature of each issue, and to editorial vagaries.

The rabbi-editor is generally a man who sees