The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 6 · December 1907
250printed page
scan 24 of 52

THE MACCABEAN

Published once every month by the Maccabean Publishing Company, of which M. B. Lande is President; and D. H. Lieberman is Secretary; whose address is 547 Broadway, New York City. Edited by Louis Lipsky.

EDITORIALS

THE NEGOTIATIONS.

Ar the time of writing, we are still in the .dark as to the nature of the interview held by Herr Wolffsohn with the Porte. That it is possible for him to obtain concessions, of great or less value, through the agency of the Zionist organization, there can be no doubt, in spite of the vagueness of the reports at pres‚ent to hand. Whatever the results, however, it is quite evident that the Actions Comite does not intend to have the diplomatic experiences of Theodor Herzl die of disuse. We are of the “opinion that many of the present disorganized, haphazard, and wholly anarchistic plans and ‚enterprises projected by ardent lovers of practical work will gain from any effort to’ establish an official relation, once more, with the "Turkish government. It is idle for us to dream of various enterprises in Palestine, and to appeal to our people for assistance for such ‚enterprises, when at any moment the government may place all our work in jeopardy. There is such a thing as foolish courage; and it is foolish courage to sav that we should scnd our people over to Palestine, and establish industries over there, at the risk of complete annihilation if the Sultan alters his present benevolent disposition. It is true, a concession is nothing more than a license, revocable at will, but a concession has the value of legality, which is always an asset in the diplomatic world.

Our Jaffa correspondent, a reliable and cautious Zionist, reports that many of our people are leaving Palestine for lack of industrial openings. The tax upon crops is a heavy burden. The repugnance of the governmental officials for industrial progress is a serious handicap. The consequences of these restrictions is a lack of faith in the future of personal ventures. Practical work, without the

bolstering influence of direct political negotiations is bound, in time, to result in complete stagnation and retrogression.

This is not a move that in any way affects practical work for the worse. On the contrary, it must produce that confidence, which we now lack, though so many of us are quite enthusiastic and zealous in our desire to do something at once. It is wisely precautionary, and as a measure of this sort, should be received with the approval of all Zionists. And above all, it should be remembered, that should Herr Wolffsohn succeed, in whatever respect, only the externalties of our movement will be affected, and our duty will still continue to be in the direction of awakening the consciousness of the Jewish people of their national future.

THE SITUATION IN NEW YORK.

TBE condition of Zionism in New York has been variously diagnosed in times past, and there has been no end of reasons given for the weakness of our organization in what is actually the largest Jewish center in the world. At one time, when dissatisfied persons wanted to have something to denounce as the cause of their own failure, the Federation was said to be to blame for disorganization, distrust, and general apathy. When the Federation had finally convinced the critics of its good faith, then it was said that Zionism was weak because we had no Yiddish press. Now that the Federation has been making headway in that direction, and a fund is being collected for a Yiddish paper, there are still many who ascribe our failure to the inability of the Federation to afhliate the Russian contingent, although the facts show that we do have with us a large proportion of the energetic workers among that element, and numerous additional recruits are reported.

The truth is that Zionists are timid and ignorant of the first rules of discipline in the city of New York, no matter how ardent they may be as Zionists. It has been impossible to maintain an efficient organization because our Zionists have never given the right sort of allegiance to the central authority. The mandates of conventions have been repudiated by organized Zionists; just dues have been refused;