Zionism In A Nutshell
CAN the process of Israel's dissolution which is now in progress everywhere be checked under the conditions of Jewish dispersion?
Is the ultimate disappearance of the Jew, which seems to be the unavoidable culmination of his denationalization, a consummation to be wished, or is it desirable that at least a saving remnant be preserved by placing it in such congenial surroundings as would make rehabilitation and growth possible?
By the way one answers these crucial questions, one’s attitude toward Zionism may be ascertained, provided one is not so blind to historical conditions as to deny that dissolution is at work in the midst of our people.
The Zionistic point of view is based on the conviction that Israel must ultimately succumb to the constantly increasing dissolving influences which surround it everywhere. It is a natural process similar to that which turns iron into magnet when placed in the midst of overwhelming magnetic influences. The Zionist's answer to the question as to whether such a process of complete submersion could be checked under the conditions of dispersion must necessarily be in the negative.
On the other hand, the Zionist also believes that the process of dissolution has not yet succeeded in drying up the strength of the Jewish people completely, and that the Jew, in his collective capacity, still retains a living spark capable of development, and if the strongest Jewish types surviving (i. e., those who struggle the hardest against submersion and dissolution) should be given a proper place more or less removed from dissolving influences, and time, there is no reason why they should not create conditions most congenial to the Jew, and why the Jewish genius should not again contribute something of its own to the world.
In this sense the second question must be answered by the Zionist.
Of all those who are opposed to Zionism the most consistent is he who admits that the
ultimate dissolution of Israel is desirable, the sooner the better, and that the world would lose nothing by its disappearance—a view often expressed in various Jewish quarters. All other anti-Zionistic or non-Zionistic reasons are merely convenient subterfuges for the purpose of dodging the real issue. Their inconsistency is only excusable by ignorance of the subject on the part of those who advance such reasons.
A noted Jewish historian published an article against Zionism some time ago, in which he attempted to prove by historical data, that Zionism is nothing more than a reaction following anti-Jewish outbreaks. He said, among other things:
"After the expulsion from Spain in 1492 we have the messianic movements of Asher Laemmlein (1507) and of David Reubeni (1522). The terrible massacre of the Polish Jews by the hordes of Chmelnicky (1648-1655) is followed by the messianic movement of Sabbathai Zebi (1666). The Damascus affair is followed by a number of pamphlets advocating the resettlement of Palestine, like Jehuda Alkalay's Kol Kore and Nachalath Jehuda. The reaction, which began in Germany with the repeal of the 'Grundrechte' in 1851, is certainly responsible for Hirsch Kalischer's Derichath Zion (1860), and for M. Hess' Rom und Jerusalem. The Russian May laws of 1882 inaugurated the present national movement in Russia, and the election of Lueger as Mayor of Vienna (1895) was followed by Herzl's Judenstaat in 1896."
He might have added the journey of Nachmanides (1195-1270) and the emigration of about 300 Rabbis from France and England about a century or so thereafter, and many earlier attempts to resettle Palestine, which events in their turn have also been preceded by persecution. But if he intended by such a compilation of historical events incidental to Jewish dispersion to crush Zionism, he missed