Charter or Concession
III
The question arises which is the right and the mare exnedient rnurce tn take.
Zionism, like any other social movement, is subject to the laws of evolution. The Zionists must be guided by the principle that the object is nothing, but the movement is everything. Our object is to “procure a legally secured home in Palestine” or, more plainly—the integral regeneration of the Jewish people on its historical soil. This is our object, which is at the other end of an involved evolution. The desire to achieve the object at once is utopian, just as socialism was utopian, when it promised a rapid automatic realization of its aims. The reality of life compelled the socialists to give up this alluring plan and devote themselves to a gradual reform of the social organism. The reality of life compels us too, to abandon the utopian phase of our development and work along a definite course for the normal evolution of the Jewish forces. The social democrats, by their endeavors to establish an eight-hour labor day, to introduce socialistic legislation, do not give up their ultimate aim, but utilize these palliative measures to strengthen the material and moral forces required for its attainment. The Zionists for the attainment of their final object ought also to do immediate and actual work, securing concessions in Palestine; thus they will bring about a greater concentration of the forces of the Jewish people, and, what is most important to us, by these means they will strengthen the bond between our Gegenwartsarbeit and our Zukunftstaat. This argument is entirely overlooked by our diplomats.
At present, there is no connection between the work in the Diaspora and that of Palestine, but it should be created out of the experiences of real life, of which immigration is a great factor. This connection can be created only by immediate active work for our future. Neither the inert expectation of a charter, nor the accumulation of social strength in the Dias-
pora only, can establish that link between the present and the future; in fact, passive expectation does not reason with actual life. As I have remarked elsewhere, the influence of our diplomats is in direct proportion to the strength of our Organization, to the extent and depth of our movement. No organization of any kind can be maintained by a Zukunftsmusik, by a remote future. Hopes will suffice for centuries, when their object is the vision of expectation; but when it is necessary to incite activity, they are insufficient, especially when these hopes are remote of realization.
The first six years of Zionist activity demonstrated what expectations alone can accomplish. In these six years comparatively splendid results were obtained, but no more can be achieved unless actual work is done. The Organization must unavoidably weaken, if it should confine itself to the policy of hope. Thus diplomatic Zionism must bring about an immediate realization of its great object, or it is doomed.
Herzl realized this. After the Fourth Congress he advocated an active work and various Hebungsfragen in the Diaspora; but, at the same time, he overlooked the fact that one cannot stop in the middle of the course, and seimism, which, in fact, is charterism from below, appeared as the natural consequence of such a policy. Another fact is also overlooked, that the present is not connected with the future, and the gulf between the two will widen more and more.
The unwished-for appearance of territorialism and seimism are the best evidence of the false bases upon which political charterism is founded. They are both regarded as its illegitimate children, whom it tries to cast off; but in reality they are its offspring and successors. They appeared not as the product of the legitimate development of charterism, but simply as the result of opportunism. Charterism in its psychology and construction is based on the idea of a quick and mechanical creation of