ment. The authorities quoted above may also be serviceable in elucidating this point.
III. He infers that an attempt to force the hand of Providence would be disastrous, and that Zionism has not the sanction of a divine command.
The success of any right cause has always been coupled, in the minds of men, with its divine origin. But the absence of a divine command cannot be known a priori. A just cause cannot be brushed aside by the assertion of any mortal that God has not spoken. It is enough for our purpose that we feel that the cause of righteousness and the highest well-being of our people, is to be served by the success of our endeavors, to warrant our assertion that the God of Israel does speak through a movement that aims to free His peo- ole.
IV. He agrees with Zionism in so far as it means a return to Jewish ideals, but political Zionism goes beyond and outside of a return to Jewish ideals.
What are Jewish ideals? They are certain definite hopes that relate to the physical and spiritual well-being of the Jewish race. A return to the ideals of living must mean an effort on the part of the Jewish people to make them an ever-present influence in their lives. We claim that these ideals are impossible of realization without the establishment of a Jewish nation upon its own territory. Without the re-establishment these ideals are nothing but vague, useless hopes that had better be forgotten if nothing is to be done for their realization. Mr. Schiff seems to agree with Zionism in its ideal aspects, but balks at the idea of doing anything to actualize them. This seems to be a curious state of mind for one who is accustomed to deal with things that can be weighed and measured.
V. Zionism is not incompatible with patriotism, but in its political doctrine it must create a lien on citizenship and limits it.
A denial and an afflirmation of the same thing. This inconsistency must be credited to Mr. Schiff’s well known philanthropic spirit, and to his desire to modify his first opinion. But he takes away with his left hand, and returns the same compliment with his right.
' VI. He retorts that it is political Zionisma that has furnished new armaments to the anti-Semites (the constant complaint of the Jews in (eormany)
This an insult to and an underestimation of the resourcefulness of the anti-Semites. There were anti-Semites in the time of Mordecai, when political Zionism was unknown; and Samballat's pernicious activity did not deter Ezra from his work of restoration. The armaments of anti-Semites are provided, we contend, by the anomalous position of the Jewish people, and not by Zionism. Jewish policy has too often been guided by a fright inspired by anti-Semitism. Zionism has come to alter that undignified and unworthy policy, and it asks that we look towards the interests of the Jewish people primarily, without regard to anti-Semites. What Stoecker may say does not interfere with our equanimity.
VII. If Zionism is to be a place of refuge only for the persecuted, it is an insult to them, for, presumably, Zion is not considered fit for the non-persecuted.
Zionism is a question that concerns the Jewish race as such, and hence is no question of groups or individuals located here or there in persecuting or non-persecuting lands. The inner desire and the self-determination of the Jewish race will determine the character of those who will be inspired to return.
VIII. Personal assurances of his interest in the welfare of his hard-suffering co-religionists.
No one has ever questioned the fine spirit of philanthropy, and the willingness to be generous, of Mr. Schiff, but it is to be regretted that he has not learned that Zionism is working in the same direction of obviating the necessity of that philanthropy which, in the United States, seems to have absorbed almost all that there is left of Jewish life. Jewish philanthropy is sick with the common ailment of all philanthropy. Zionism is a radical cure of Jewish ailments; it is the policy of self-help pitted against the enervating influences of static philanthropy.
IX. The emigration solution cannot solve the Russian Jewish problem in its entirety, and