The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 5 · November 1907
185printed page
scan 3 of 52
Facsimile · scan 3 of 52
Scan of p. 185
Text · transcribed from the scan

they chose for habitation, but as long as they remained in Palestine, they would not get a cent nor the smallest job. There was nothing to do but obey. The majority of them went to America, some returned to Russia. These men have become the bitterest anti-Zionists and even anti-Semites that you ever met and have done more harm to our cause than can be imagined. They are a living proof of our ignorance, incapacity and want of genuine interest in Palestine.

I have made a special study of the ICA and its methods and can say this: Where the ICA works with the aid of local men as in the States, in Russia and some other places; that is, where the ICA simply supplies the money and local men do the work, everything goes well and Baron de Hirsch's fund is proving of great benefit to the people, as was the ardent wish of the late philanthropist. But where the ICA undertakes to do any work on its own account, it is bound to fail. See what enormous sums were spent on the Argentine colonization and what miserable results are there to show for it.

This colonization absorbs one-sixth of the total income of the ICA, that is, $500,000 yearly, just to keep on the land about 6,000 souls and if it were not for the continual influx of new people, the colonies would have been without colonists long ago.

Each family settled in Argentina cost the fund no less than 10,000 pesetos. Do you think for a moment that any farmer, especially a Jewish one, can start life with a debt of $10,000 and pay off capital and interest even at the smallest rate and at the same time make a living? Never! And we see that the colonists not only pay no debts, but often require more assistance from the administration.

Some years ago a small number of Jewish agricultural laborers left the South of Russia and went, at their own expense, to Argentine being sure of getting employment in the Jewish colonies there, but they reckoned without theiı host. The tchinorniks of the ICA forbade the colonists to give these newcomers any work whatever, and the latter, having exhausted their scanty means, were compelled to migrate to the nearest towns. The ICA administrators these absolute autocrats nf the cnlonies, could

not bear the presence of any free element, thaf is, any persons that did not depend upon them for a living and so the laborers were ordered' out the same as was done in Palestine. And: there are the people into whose hands is: placed the management of $3,000,000 of Jewıch natınnal mnnev vearlv ! .

I must not overlook another, most important side of the question, the moral one. The ICA, whose chief managers are French Jews, to whom everything Jewish is quite strange and evidently antipathetic, has always looked upon the Russian Jew as a schnorrer and by treating him as such, has easily turned him into one.

The worst features of officialdom and red-tapeism have been transferred to Palestine and the much-benefited Russian Jew found himself from the beginning in the stagnant, stifling atmosphere of bureaucracy, amounting almost to slavery; he could not walk a step without the permission of the agents and taskmasters, sent to instruct and supervise him. His complaints, if ever they reached headquarters, were disregarded and taken as a sign of his rebellious nature and ungratefulness.

Even at the present moment in the colonies managed by the ICA no meeting of colonists can take place without the permission of the manager. One colony is bossed by a gentleman from Russia, who. during his stay in Palestine, has managed to acquire quite a small fortune in the shape of vineyards and other plantations valued at $50,000. He behaves like a regular Pasha and in his presence a colonist dare not sit down, but must, like a soldier,' stand at attention. Of course, he is on the best of terms with the local (Turkish) administra-' tion and can crush anybody who would dare criticize or oppose him in ayy way.—Now, can we wonder that all methods of colonizing practized until now, have failed? What, then, is to be done beside big talk to keep the Jewish farmer and laborer on the land. All the methods tried so far failed, I say failed because we cannot call it a success when millions have been spent that can never be repaid.

Prof. Otto Warburg gives a plain solution of the question and I hope the esteemed pr>fessor will not be content with simply throwing out a hint and giving good advice. but will