The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 5 · November 1907
214printed page
scan 32 of 52
Facsimile · scan 32 of 52
Scan of p. 214
Text · transcribed from the scan

OCTOBER MEETING OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE

A meeting of the Executive Committee of the Federation of American Zionists was held on Monday evening, October 7, at the Hotel Marie Antoinette, New York. Present were: Dr. Harry Friedenwald, in the chair, Mr. S. Abel, Dr. H. J. Epstein, Dr. I. Freidlander, Mr. J. Hirsch (by invitation), Mr. D. H. Lieberman, Mr. L. Lipsky, Mr. L. D. Livingston, Mr. E. W. Lewin-Epstein, Mr. H. Newstad, Mr. N. Prensky, Dr. A. M. Radin and the Secretary. Apologies for non-attendance were received from Dr. R. Gottheil and Mr. Henry Jackson.

All arrangements had been made for a propaganda tour by Mr. A. H. Fromenson throughout the country. Mr Fromenson is, unfortunately, now suffering from a serious illness; and all arrangements must, for the oresent, remain in abevance.

The Chairman also informed the Committee of the misfortune of Dr. A. Wolf, of St. Louis, a member of the Actions Comite, who lost his wife and child through an accident. The Secretary was instructed to express the deep and sincere sympathy of the Federation to Dr. Wolf in his grief.

The Chairman referred to the controversy as to the incompatibility of Zionism and American patriotism, which had arisen with Mr. Jacob H. Schiff in consequence of the latter's open letter to Prof. S. Schechter, recently published in the American Hebrew. The President had replied to this letter, as had also a number of individual Zionists. An editorial reply had been made in THE MACCABAEAN. The holding of a mass-meeting by the New York Council had given the Federation an opportunity to make an official reply to Mr. Schiff.

The Secretary then reported as to the visit of Dr Shmaryahu Lewin to this country during the coming winter. Dr. Lewin went to Palestine at the expense of the Federation. It was expected that Dr. Lewin would send reports of his investigations to the Federation for publication as a preliminary to his coming to America for the purpose of gathering a large sum of money for educational purposes in Palestine. During the Hague Congress, a small confer-

ence had been held with Dr. Lewin. The members of this conference were Dr Lewin, Mr. Lewin-Epstein, Mr. Kamaiky, Dr. Schlossinger, Dr. Wolf, of St. Louis, Dr. Tschlenow, Herr Kahn, of the Hague, Mr. Moser, of England, and the Secretary. Upon the basis of a letter received from the President of the Federation, the conference arrived at the conclusion that Dr. Lewin ought to be invited to come to this country; that his traveling expenses be covered from the funds collected by him; that he go to a health resort for some time to recuperate from the severe strain of his work in Palestine; and also that a certain sum be allowed Dr. Lewin for the maintenance of his family during an absence of at least six months. Dr. Lewin requested a sum of 3,000 Marks for this purpose. The conference was unanimous in the opinion that the responsibility of paying a sum of money to Dr. Lewin for the maintenance of his family might safely be assumed. Herr Wolffsohn had, in the meantime, advanced the sum of 1,500 Marks for this purpose. Dr. Lewin and the Secretary were altogether agreed that the success of the tour would be dependent upon the ability of the Federation to form a committee to take charge of the arrangements; such a,committee to be entirely independent of the Federation, which would, however, insist upon a Zionist majority. The committee would consist of several prominent non-Zionists and several leading Zionists; and its purpose and status would be definitely made known.

After considerable discussion, it was decided to try to enlist the interest of a number of persons outside of the Zionist organization in the Palestine education problem. It was also de cided that the extending of an invitation to Dr. Lewin be contingent upon success in organizing the committee. It was further resolved to inform Dr. Lewin and Herr Wolffsohn of the present status of the matter; and to instruct the committee to take no definite action until it had reported to the Executive Committee.

The Secretary read letters from Herr Wolffsohn and from the Central Bureau referring to a resolution of the Congress that every organized Zionist contribute at least one dollar as a party tax to the central organization in Cologne, The various federations were asked to report collections weekly or bi-weekly, and tc for-