The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 5 · November 1907
209printed page
scan 27 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN.
209

THE MACCABAEAN

Published once every month by the Maccabaean Pub. lishing Company, of which M. Lande is President; and D. H. Lieberman is Secretary; the address of those officers is 547 Broadway, New York City. Edited by LOUIS LIPSKY

NOVEMBER, 1907

EDITORIALS

SILENCE FROM DR. SILVERMAN.

Dr. Silverman has not offered an apology to Zionists for his malicious libel, nor has he accepted the challenge to prove his statement as to the character of the influences in the Zionist movement. He has thus forfeited the right to be considered as an honest opponent, or as a man whose utterances have any weight with right-thinking Jews. A rabbi who goes out of his way to libel men and women engaged in a movement for the betterment of Jewish life, who, when confronted with a challenge to prove his statement, takes refuge in cowardly silence, merits the contempt which the libel aroused.

END OF SCHIFF CONTROVERSY.

Mr. Schiff's condemnation of Zionism may be dismissed with the full and complete reply which Mr. Kazmann, our zealous comrade, has written. Fearing the effect upon the general Jewish position in America, Mr. Schiff, whose loyalty to Jewish interests as he sees them has never been questioned, hastened to modify his position on the vexations problem of the double patriotism of the Jew, but in modifying it, he, unfortunately for himself, reiterated certain views on Zionism which we, as Zionists, could not receive without a protest. Mr. Kazmann has voiced that protest for us.

- We have no doubt as to the harmful effect of Mr. Schiff’s statements, not only to the general Jewish cause, but to Zionism as well, and we would urge upon the Federation an official declaration to the Jewish people, setting forth our position in a more elaborate manner than the polemics in the Jewish press allowed.

There are hundreds of Jews in this country who will accept Mr. Schiff's statements as paramount authority, and their minds should be disabused of certain fallacies in Mr. Schiff's line of reasoning.

Mr. Schiff has opened the campaign for us. He has provided us with the means for getting the attention of those Jews who have litherto thought very little about Zionism except to condemn it. We should not neglect the opportunity thus offered us.

SHOLOM ASCH AND MORALITY.

THE virile sketches of Sholom Asch have won for him the admiration of all Jews, but the fact that he has written those sketches should not blind us to the other fact that his "God of Vengeance," a drama in three acts, played in New York recently, for the first time, is a decidedly unpleasant and destructive play.

ee ee Fee re nl Zu: It would be deplorable if our movement stood as sponsor of imitators or disciples of the school of literature, which is decadent in name and destructive in fact, but which be cause it treats of Jewish life, must be treated as Jewish. Whatever we may be, whatever circumstances have made of us, we have re tained our native sanity with regard to spirit ual, as well as material things. There ıs nothing in Jewish precedent that warrants the inference that physical or psychological obsessions, which have appeared in the literature as well as the life of certam people, have’a natural parallel development among us. There has come into Jewish life as the direct outcome of oppression and revolutionary ferment, certain features that are not Jewish, but we Zionists, in the period of our national rejuvenation, would not take with us into the land of our hope those features of the Goluth that savor of Babylon and the degenerate practices of the oriental malversions of human nature. We want our reborn nation to be a strong, not an infected, diseased nation.

“The God of WVengeance” as a realistic drama, taken out of its decadent, symbolistic wrappings, might have been a sharp criticism of the double life, the abnormal life, the Jewish people are forced to lead. Above, in the atmosphere of home, an indefinite desire for godliness; below, in the atmosphere of the brothel, degradation and the profanation of the nobility of man’s nature. This double status cannot be maintained. The pure will not escape contamination. It is bound to be infected by the basement life, and when the