The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 5 · November 1907
194printed page
scan 12 of 52
194
THE MACCABARAM.

by a third party, which would be ready to move its army in defense of our privileges. Stated more clearly, the charter obtained from Turkey can only then become a charter when it will be recognized and supported by one or several of the Powers. From Turkey we obtain a concession, a guaranteed charter only from the great Powers. We must once for all clear the Zionist camp of this confusion. The subject should be clearly understood.

From the above it is evident that the Zionist policy has but two avenues of activity:

ee ee Ads And I. Those who desire to come into imme. diate possession of a charter, with public legal guarantees, must cease all negotiations with Turkey, and look for salvation in negotiations with large Powers, who are more or less interested in the solution of the Jewish question, as well as in a modification of the status quo in Palestine. They have two ways to follow: first, from below, with strong financial institutions, a better disciplined organization; second, from above, a genial diplomacy represented by one or several persons, who can easily gain the sympathy and the confidence of the European powers, and who have behind them the orgazination and its institutions, and who could force the Jewish question into a prominent position in the world of politics.

Those who think that the national ideal can be achieved at once, at one stroke, who fear for the fate of Jewish colonization if it be not guaranteed and protected by the civilized world, and, finally, those who believe that this is the only way to finance an immense enterprise of a large colonization of the Jewish masses, are in favor of this diplomatic course.

The defenders of this course of action argue that neither the Jewish Colonial Bank, the National Fund, nor the ICA, together with all other philanthropic institutions, possesses the

colossal means necessary to carry on a mass colonization. The means must be furnished by international capital, which must be protected by guaranteed enterprises. With a charter guaranteed by one or several powers, the Jews will be able to secure an advantageous loan in the market of international capital.

This method depends exclusively upon diplomatic negotiations. It is surprising that those who were loudest in their demands for guarantees, and who would not content themselves with public legal guarantees, but demanded international guarantees, soon thereafter became the bitterest opponents of so-called diplomatic Zionism.

2. The other course open to us is apparently more prolonged and slower. Palestine is in the possession of Turkey; therefore, it is necessary to negotiate with Turkey. Turkey will not permit the interference of any other power. Against itself it can issue no guaranteed char ter, but only concessions. These we must en deavor to obtain. The substance and extent of these concessions vary, and the Zionist organization must conform itself to the circumstances. The evolutionary method of advance is of equal advantage both to Turkey and to the Zionists. Turkey, always in control of the concessions, will be able to learn the important significance of the introduction of a normal culture in Palestinee At the same time, the Zionists provided with concessions, will be enabled to begin immediate practical work in Palestine. The disputes as to the fitness of the masses, the strength of the organization, will cease, for the substance and extent of the concessions will be in direct proportion to the fitness, the means of the masses and the organization.

(To be continued.)