Charter or Concession
By Dr. D. Pasmanik
(Continued.)
HAVING explained the nature of a charter, we pass now to Zionist policies. Two things must be borne in mind: first, that Zionism does not aim to exploit, but to colonize the land; second, that Turkey maintains its own sovereignty, and is the legal as well as the actual possessor of the land. What do we Zionists represent?
To the outside world, the Zionist organization represents a moral value, but, under certain conditions, it may develop important significance, as was the case when the Uganda proposition was considered, and yet, neither the Actions Comite nor the Congress is the proper agency to enter into negotiations with governments. From the point of view of legal authority, the Congress may carry on negotiations only through the Bank; that is, in reality, in the eyes of the world, we are a trust or stock company, in a peculiar form. This fact cannot be concealed in the phraseology of an international significance of the Jewish question, now expressed in the emigration of the Jewish masses. In their official organ, the S. S. Party charged the Jewish bourgeoisie with not discharging their obligations to the Jews by not obtaining a territory for the emigrating masses. This complaint, however, is an indictment of the present capitalist system under which a territory may be secured in this way, and only in this way. Under the present system a territory is secured either by conquest of arms, which is not at all considered by Zionists, or by the purchase of land with money. When the S. S. speak of diplo matic negotiations, they speak, in fact, of ne gotiations by means of financial institutions Even to the genial Zangwill, no territory will be given without presenting some material reasons, shares paid up in full by private persons or by some organization. We are pressed to make these remarks, for there exists among
our young men a frenzy at the expression of certain ideas, and they are misled by fine words. Much has been said against diplomacy, and yet, the first thing proposed by the S. S. is a proposal in favor of diplomatic negotiations. But under the present system, diplomatic negotiations unsupported by a powerful army or immense financial resources, lead to nothing, or, at most, in case of urgent necessity, to an expression of platonic sympathy, and nothing more.
The first prerequisite we do not possess; the second we have begun to gather. Consequently, the Zionists, neglecting nothing that can be of a moral advantage, must begin negotiations in the form of a corporation.
We desire to secure Palestine or the adjacent lands. Therefore, we must begin negotiations with the actual owner of the country, the Turkish Government. The best we can aim for is an extensive concession, but only a concession. It may be limited to the right to colonize the land, or we may be given political and economic—that is, public-legal privileges, that will enable us to develop the Jewish nation. But these privileges will be only a concession, or, in the words of Werner, “Something issuing exclusively from the Turkish Government, in regard to which we may (or must) presuppose other Powers cannot interfere.” That is, stated more clearly, something which in itself does not contain any public legal guaranty. If the name is of any use, let the concession be called “The Turkish Charter,” but the name or the form is not important to us, the essence of the privilege is what we must take into consideration. It is, therefore, important for us to know that a charter implies a guaranty, and that the Turkish Charter can contain only public legal privileges, but no guaranty. Turkey can issue no guaranty against itself; this must be granted