The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 4 · October 1907
144printed page
scan 4 of 52
144
THE MACCABAEAN.

Jacob H. Schiff's Views Denounced at Zionist Meeting

A meeting which accomplished the double purpose of welcoming the American delegates to the Congress and denouncing Mr. Jacob H. Schiff for his ill-advised attack on the patriotism of American Zionists, was held on Saturday evening, Sept. 14, at Cooper Union, New York. Dr. Harry Friedenwald, president of the Federation, delivered the address of the evening in reply to Mr. Schiff, which was also an exposition of Zionist principles. Dr. Friedenwald said:

“Could we but send our friends who are not Zionists to our congresses and give them an object lesson in Jewish ardor, in Jewish self-sacrifice, in Jewish hopefulness, in Jewish idealism, in Jewish self-confidence and in Jewish self-respect, we would have many of them with us—for these things are contagious, and he who has a Jewish heart which beats in unison with Jewish emotions feels sensations that are new to him. Let not those go to our congress whose hearts are cold and frozen; ‚they will tell you only of excitement and tumult, of visionary dreamers and enthusiasts. For it requires sympathy as well as ears to catch the true note of this great gathering and the eye needs the aid of the surging blood to see into the real inwardness of its actions and its impulses.

And without these the whole Zionist movement cannot be understood—and because of their lack, it is so widely misunderstood. The objects which we have before us may be tersely expressed in a few words and these are easily comprehended. Any one can understand the plain words of the Basle platform: “Zionism strives toward a legally assured home for the Jewish people in Palestine” But it takes imagination to understand its ultimate significance. It needs a heart to feel the change it will produce in Jewish conditions.

The Jew who knows not what role his ancestors played in the world's development, who feels no pride in his people's past; why should he sympathize with our ambitious

plans for Israel’s regeneration? For him whose heart is bound by no ties to the land of his fathers, what interest is there in its development? The Jew who has no confidence in his people, who sees only the stigma of suffering and oppression, the scars of the rack and the pogrom, why shall he listen to us when we build hopes on this people’s future? He who does not feel and smart under the contumely, disgrace and dishonor our people suffer in almost every portion of the globe— he who never thinks of the abject bottomless misery, of the unspeakable agony which the greater part of our people are constantly suffering year in and year out—every day, every moment (unless the daily papers happen to print in glaring lines the sickening, horrible details of another massacre—why should he concern himself about the future of his people) —when their present does not concern him?

And that is the reason why we Zionists lay so much weight upon what some call sentiment; that is why we value those forces which you will find in our ranks, the intense love of our people, the solidarity and sense of oneness with our brethren, wherever they may have been scattered, whatever the language they speak or the garments they wear. The readiness, nay, the eagerness to serve our people, the awkward national self-consciousness, the sense of Jewish dignity and Jewish manhood and Jewish honor, these cannot be counted or measured or weighed, they cannot be used for statistics, but they are the only means by which we can carve out our destinies. Without them all other means would be naught. With them all, other means must and shall be obtained!

We have seen how this country responded with sympathy after the horrors of the first Kischineff massacre—because we brought the facts before them; what has become of this sympathy now? Jews and Gentiles have forgotten and the public is indifferent. Another