The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 3 · September 1907
132printed page
scan 46 of 62
132
THE MACCARAEAN.

endeavor to create a separate fund for this purpose. It further requests the Palestinian Department to take steps for the development of a Hebrew Secondary School in Palestine.

Mr. Wolffsohn then took the Chair.

Mr. J. Cowen opened the debate by stating that he did not oppose the recommendations, and hoped they would be adopted. He was, however, of opinion that preliminary to any action, steps should be taken for the withdrawal of the prohibition by the Turkish Government of the settlement of Jews in Palestine, That Government should be informed that those Jews who desired to take up their residence in Palestine were willing to become Turkish subjects. He appealed to Congress to show a spirit of tolerance to those who differed in opinion from the majority. The lack of tolerance at the last Congress had led to the secession of Mr. Zangwill, which was a great loss to Zionism. He repeated the words of Dr. Nordau that political Zionism must triumph; if not national liquidation would ensue.

Herr Davis Trietsch followed with a long speech, in the course of which he was frequently directed by the President to confine his observations to the question before the meeting. In order that the time of the Congress should not be further wasted (the President mentioned that sixty names had been entered on the list of speakers), a motion was submitted limiting speakers to ten minutes. The motion was carried, but a further motion to select only eight speakers was rejected.

Mr. L. J. Greenberg said that he supported the propositions generally, as he had always been in favor of practical work in Palestine. Before the words "practical work" had come out of the mouths of many of those who spoke them so loudly that day—at the time when the Commission was sent to East Africa—he had written a letter to the Actions Committee urging that practical work might be begun in Palestine. He, however, had always held that such work must go hand in hand with work—so-called political work—outside Palestine. He was glad to follow Mr. Trietsch, because he (Mr. Trietsch) formed a lesson which they would do well at that moment to take to heart. He (Mr. Greenberg)

remembered the time when Mr. Trietsch was hounded from the tribune for venturing to suggest colonization in Cyprus—to-day Cyprus. was in the “prescribed area” of their proposed colonizing operations. Surely that should teach them toleration of opinion towards those {rom whom they differed in detail, and the absence of which, together with suspicion of motives, had cost them so dear. Look at the men whom they had lost or who at least were not present at that Congress. Could they not see they weakened the movement by every loss they made? He deplored the fact that some of their friends had left the movement—he had always said they were wrong in doing so, but he deplored still more the spirit in face of which they had fled. Mr. Trietsch had twitted the Actions Committee for paucity of their political work. This came with singular effect from one who had assisted in rejecting as Congress did the East Africa scheme, and which action had snapped a link in the chain of their political work it was not easy to repair or replace. That, again, was the result of intolerance and of distrust. He accepted fully the decision of the Seventh Congress, much as he regretted it, for he regarded as even more important than the opportunities that decision put an end to, the maintenance of their movement and loyalty to Congress. He regretted not to see in the recommendations before them, one for the establishment of a real working Committee in Palestine.

The Rev. Dr. Gaster said that those who were in favor of practical work in Palestine were taunted with being Chovevi Zionists, but the great question was so to work in Palestine as to lay the foundation for the eventual carrying out of the Basile program. All work of that kind was entirely different from what was known as Chovevi Zionism. No one who favored the promotion of practical work for a moment lost sight of the political work, for by carrying out their policy they were furthering the object they all had in view. One important point had been entirely lost sight of, and that was the significance of Zionism for the Jews in the diaspora. Many Zionists were thinking only of obtaining Palestine for the one or two millions who could possibly live there. What about the eight millions who