The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 3 · September 1907
129printed page
scan 43 of 62

mittee had allowed a favorable opportunity which presented itself for diplomatic action to pass by, but he could assure Dr. Nossig that he knew absolutely nothing of such an opportunity or of an offer which it was alleged had been made. Replying to Dr. Pasmanik, he said that they all agreed that practical work must be done in Palestine, but proposals in this respect were made to them by people who did not know the meaning of the term practical work. There were some who said that Dr. Herzl had been opposed to work of this nature; this was not so, for the Anglo-Palestine Bank and other institutions in Palestine were initiated by him. The Actions Committee were now carrying on that practical work, which he favored, but about which he did not talk. What, on the other hand, had those speakers who were clamoring for practical work, done in that direction? It had been said that a mandate had been given to establish an Agrarian Bank in Palestine. Well, on investigation it had been found that such a bank was impossible, as the Turkish law was against it; but, despite this insuperable obstacle, when he reported the difficulty, he was answered by Congress: We will have an Agrarian Bank. He did not consider such a course of action to be practical work. Dr. Pasmanik had demanded a leader who would lead. If they expected from him what they had found in Dr. Herzl, and he had not come up to their expectations, the fault lay not with him, but with Congress in electing him. Again, the same speaker had said that when they had money they would be in a position to work. He (Herr Wolffsohn) quite agreed, and asked Dr. Pasmanik to see that Russia, which contained the largest number of Zionists, provided them with ample means. It should not be forgotten that the Smaller Actions Committee consisted of seven members only, living in different countries. It was extremely difficult therefore to bring them together whenever the need for a meeting arose. If it was desired to strengthen the Committee, or to extend it by the formation of a bureau in Berlin, he would give the proposal his support. Herr Trietsch had spoken as though the Actions Committee were envious of the Ito. Nothing was further from their thoughts. If the Ito should meet with success

they would rejoice, but its work was not Zionism. If the Actions Committee had not performed as much Zionistic work as they themselves desired, their work had been Jewish. The relief work on account of the pogroms in Russia was not Zionistic, but it was Jewish. As regarded interference in the internal policy of the different countries, neither Congress nor the Committee could tolerate such interference, and he believed the Congress would agree with him on that point. He agreed with previous speakers that an income of 80,000 marks was inadequate for effective work; but the remedy was simple: Obtain more adherents for Zionism and collect more shekels. Then the Committee would be able to do more political work.

Dr. Pasmanik, as a personal explanation, denied having stated that Dr. Herzl was not in favor of practical work. To show that he (Dr. Pasmanik) was not unappreciative of the work of the President and the Actions Committee, he tendered them cordial thanks for their work during the past two years.

Herr N. Sokolow, General Secretary of the Actions Committee, replied to criticisms of that body's report, which he had read the previous day.

FRIDAY. August 16.

President: Dr. Gaster.

Professor Warburg read the report of the Palestine Commission.

REPORT OF THE PALESTINE COMMISSION.

Professor Warburg said that he agreed with the President that it was not desirable to talk too much or too loudly concerning the action which it was intended to take in Palestine. That the Palestine Commission had not yet achieved much, was chiefly due to the divergent opinions among the members as to the course which should be taken. He therefore was of opinion that more unity of action was eminently desirable. As to the steps already taken, investigations were being made with the view of establishing agricultural and industrial undertakings. Those investigations were being carried on slowly, but steadily and entirely in the sense of the Basle program. During the last two years a scientific investigation had been conducted in the territory stretching from