Mr. Schiff's Letter to Dr. Schechter
A letter, dated August 8, was written by Mr. Schiff in reply to one from Prof. S. Schechter, in which he said, in part:
Speaking as an American, I cannot for a moment concede, that one can be, at the same time, a true American and an honest adherent of the Zionist ‚Movement. The men whom you mention by name may have, or may have had as far as they have passed away, the thorough conviction of a deep attachment to this country, but if they are honest Zionists—I mean if they believe and hope and labor for an ultimate restoration of Jewish political life and the reestablishmemt of a Jewish Nation, they place a prior lien upon their citizenship, which, if there would be a possibility for their desire and plans to become effective, would prevent them from maintaining allegiance to the country, of which they now claim to be good citizens. The Jew should not for a moment feel that he has only found an “asylum” in this country; he must not feel that he is in exile and that his abode here is only a temporary or passing one. If those who come after us are to be freed from the prejudice from which this generation is, not unnaturally, suffering, we need feel that politically no one has any claim upon us but the country of which, of our free will, we have become citizens, that even if we are Jews in faith, there is no string to our citizenship. . . .
"JACOB H. SCHIFF."
REPLY OF DR. FRIEDENWALD.
Dr. Harry Friedenwald, President of the Federation of American Zionists, at once sent to the Jewish press a reply to Mr. Schiff's letter, and gave out an interview in the Baltimore News, expanding on the views expressed in the following letter:
“In the letter of Mr. Jacob H. Schiff to Professor Schechter, published in the American Hebrew of August 23, and republished in part or in whole in other papers, Mr. Schiff declares that one cannot be the same time ‘a true American and an honest adherent of the Zionist movement... He makes this statement a
moment after saying that he 'freely concedes the right of whosoever may choose to do so, to join the Zionist Movement and cannot see any good reason why anyone, who becomes a Zionist, so long as he does this from honest motives, should draw upon himself the attacks of others, who may think differently.' Perhaps Mr. Schiff does not regard the charge that an 'honest Zionist' cannot be a 'true American' is an attack upon us. I am obliged to inform you that the American Zionists regard this as a serious charge and an unwarranted attack.
“We resent being taunted with disloyalty to America and we repudiate it because we know and feel that it is not true Whether as a modern political Zionists or as a ‘Chovev Zionist,’ or as one praying the Jewish liturgy, we are all looking forward to the Restoration. The charge against one is the charge against all. I am sure that had Mr. Schiff considered this he would not have ventured to make public a statement that a Zionist cannot be a ‘true American,’ for it brands as disloyal every Jew, who prays daily before the ‘Shema,’ ‘O bring us peace from the four corners of the earth, and make us go upright to our land,’ or thrice daily ın the ‘Amidah,’ ‘Sound the great horn for our freedom; lift up the ensign to gather our exiles and gather us from the four corners of the earth, etc.,’ and ‘To Jerusalem, thy city, return in mercy, and dwell therein as thou hast spoken; rebuild it soon in our days, etc., and ‘Let our eyes behold thy return in mercy to Zion.’
"If Mr. Schiff is correct, there is one conclusion from which there is no escape, that Judaism and Americanism are incompatible and that the Jew who believes in the Judaism, that has been the religion, the hope and the life of our people during many centuries, cannot be a 'true American.' For Mr. Schiff will certainly not claim that the Jew who prays for the Restoration is entitled to the full degree of 'true American,' while he who believes or hopes or works for its realization is not!
"Yours,
