Lipsky, of the Federation. The address of Mr. Avrunin, while partisan in its tone, was a very effective appeal to the assertive qualities in Jewish life. Mr. Lipsky spoke of Jewish tendencies, and controverted the declaration of Mr. Schiff as to Americanism and Zionism. Rabbi Lasker said that the good Zionist could at the same time, and must be, a good American citizen. The Rev. Sigmund Frey spoke with a deal of Talmudical learning, but taking issue with Messrs. Lipsky and Avrunin on their interpretation of Jewish history, he evoked a terrific reply from Mr. Avrunin, which was one of the best things of the evening. The Rev. Mr. Frey is a sympathetic Zionist, but Mr. Avrunin's reply must have chilled his sympathy.
CANADIAN STATESMAN TO ZIONISTS.
The following is a copy of the letter which was recently addressed by the Right Hon. A. B. Aylesworth, Minister of Justice in Canada, to Mr. Clarence I. de Sola, President of the Federation of Zionist Societies of Canada.
DEAR SIR:
I was much impressed, this morning, with the earnestness and enthusiasm displayed by yourself and your friends at the Convention of Canadian Zionist Societies. In the few words of your address which I heard after coming into the Hall, I was struck with the practical interest of your explanation that on any family festival $1.50 contributed in memory of the occasion would plant an olive tree for some poor colonist in Palestine, and as a trifling mark of practical interest in your words I send you a cheque for $18., with the idea that, in commemoration of the 41st Dominion Day, I may be able to think that somewhere in Palestine there are twelve or more olive trees plants, one for each tribe.
I return you, also, the newspaper clippings you were good enough to send me. I have read them all with very great interest indeed, and have to thank you again for the privilege of being allowed to address your Convention to-day.
I remain,
Yours faithfully,
A. B. AYLESWORTH.
How an S. S. Became a Zionist
TO THE MACCABAEAN:
I am convinced that the readers of THE MACCABAEAN will be interested to know the impression the Zionist movement made upon a novice or, rather, a new proselyte. Of course I do not forget the fact, that no one is born a Zionist; that you have all been first Gojim, then Gerim, just like me. But your proselytism is an old one, and you have forgotten your sentiments. My present correspondence can be likened unto a young couple telling old married people the glories of their honeymoon.
I was recruited from the ranks of the rabid cosmopolitans. Painful was the process. Every time I had to yield to the argument not only of a Zionist, but even of an abstract nationalist, I felt as if I had been pierced by daggers. Is not cosmopolitanism —that cosmopolitanism which teaches: "One humanity on one earth," a beautiful dream? Should not the motto be: "Ubi sum, ibi patria!" instead of "Ubi natus sum, ibi patria?" or "Ubi cives sum, ibi patria?" "Ubi bene, ibi patria!" This motto I have long ago discarded, because I am an altruist.
After long contemplation I found that the ethnic and economic side of society do not interfere with one another. The trouble with society is not ethnic, but economic. Hence, no matter what views one has on ethnic matters, they do not interfere with his economic views.
Even if all economic misery be abolished to-day, and an economic paradise be established, mankind will still continue to be divided in nations. The nationalism that would then exist, would mean: Fraternity of nations, instead of as to-day, war of nations.
The economic and ethnic are dovetailed, yet separated. Especially have I found out the necessity of Jewish nationalism, because the lack of it means the tragic doom of that historical nation.
"Si Lyra non lyrasset, Lutherus non saltas-set!" Let me paraphrase this. "Had the S. S. not existed, I would have become an S. S.!"
