problem with his back to Europe and his eyes fixed on New York. What has been occurring behind his back did not interest him when he administered his reproof to Zionism. Nor does he understand clearly the development of Jewish life on the East Side.
II.
In his second statement on Zionism, Mr. Schiff presents the issue upon which so many German Jews rest their theoretical opposition. As a matter of fact, their opposition is really due to indifference to the Jewish future, but it is always better to have a-point, in order that the rational query, “What about the Jewish Future?’ may be met with some show of reason. We do not say, however, that Mr. Schiff raises this question from such motives. His motive is to fend off any danger to the Jewish position in America, and he actually thinks that Zionism does imperil the status of the Jews. His is the Goluth motive.
He forgets, however, that American citizenship is somewhat different from that of Germany, France and other European countries still imbued with the monarchical idea. America is the meeting place of the races of the world; it is a federation of races. Here, all racial influences meet, and, as far as possible, blend, but the mixture is not complete, and there is not one locality where the American type prevails. As a democratic, representative state, the United States embodies in its constitution the demands the state has a right to make upon the citizen; it can not exceed the authority vested in it by the constitution. Therefore, the good citizen is he who obeys the laws, pays his taxes, takes up arms in defense of his country—when it is right—and, out of enlightened self-interest is concerned in all the problems of American life. This he may do and at the same time have other interests that are not American at all. He may be devoted to Italian music, German art, to French literature, to Russian freedom, and in no way does that conflict with any duty which he owes the country of which he is a member. Mr. Schiff’s contention would be valid only in a case where the Zionist state was already in being, and when an issue in conflict with an American interest
arises. Until such an eventuality, the criticısm of the actual incompatibility of Zionism and American good citizenship is a libel on good American citizens, and will not benefit the Jews as a people or as a religious body. That man is a narrow-minded churl who would find fault with the Irish, who want to see the land of their birth free; or with the Germans, who promote a German culture ın America; or with certain Christians who take: up nıissionary work in heathen lands; for what ever these persons are doing they do in the name of a universal ideal, with which the traditions of American democracy are fully in accord. Lafayette, taking up arms with the Americans against England; the German refugees who helped the Union forces in our Civil War; did they not have the approval of their own countries first of all; were they disloyal. to France and to Germany, respectively, when they helped in the cause of freedom? The only difference in the case of Zionism lies in the fact that Zion must first be inhabited by a Jewish population, free from alien cultural influences, and industrially relieved of undue oppression. When that is realized, we shall be, absolutely, in a political sense, in the same position as are the Irısh.
It is true, our principle destroys the theory of Jewish life that as soon as a German or Russian Jew touches American soil he at once becomes an American patriot, and that when the same Russian or German touches British soil he at once becomes a screaming English chauvinist. It destroys the theory that we are American "patriots," which no one believes, and which it is to no one's interest that they should believe. What England and what America demand of us is good citizenship, and that from every point of view the Russian and German Jews are as good citizens as we have, no one is foolish enough to deny.
With Mr. Schiff’s ideas of the Jewish mission it is idle to quarrel, for the religious mission has been amply shredded. If the "“mission-Jews” speak of their mission, we declare that, if it is a mission you want, we too have a mission, the national mission, which every people must have in order to inspire it to continued self-expression and individuality.