The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 3 · September 1907
112printed page
scan 26 of 62

Now conditions have radically improved, and the wisdom of the conservatism of the Federation has been demonstrated. The appeal of the Yiddish press fund is now met with enthusiasm, and, at the same time, with caution and deliberative energy. The influx of Russian Zionists, readers and writers, the rise of Zionism as a question that deserves study and interpretation—these point to a good opportunity for an alert Zionist press. And the situation also is better appreciated. It is recognized that a propagandist press is at a disadvantage. It must depend upon the sacrifices of the adherents of the cause. True to the interests of the movement, it cannot hope for financial success for many years. A case is known of the financial success of a Yiddish party organ, but as that organ has succeeded it has become less and less a party organ, and its position is now maintained at the expense of the principles for which it stands. This a Zionist organ must be prepared to avoid, and as a consequence to suffer financially.

In short, though difficulties are in the way, it is now possible for Zionists in America to organize a Yiddish press within the confidence that writers will be forthcoming to maintain its literary standard, and that there will be Zionist workers to hold its head above water until it is able to maintain itself.

MR. SCHIFF'S SOLUTION OF THE JEWISH QUESTION.

I.

MR. JACOB H. SCHIFF'S refusal to "attack" Zionism will be better appreciated, probably, by the reformers who implored him to make the attack than by Zionists. The "Schiff" reproof is more deadly than his attack. Had he decided to give Zionism a sharp cut with his delicate rapier, there might have been an opportunity for the wounded party to join issues with him, but his reproof leaves us a scant opening for a reply.

It must be granted that Mr. Schiff's statement that Zionism is impracticable, and that its realization has no relation to immediate affairs, will have a large influence upon those timid souls who dearly love to have “authority” for their indifference to Zionism. Mr.

Schiff’s eminence as a practical man, coupled with his impeccable sincerity, and, as it were, homely piety, gives any statement he ventures to make thie authority of experience and altruism, which, to the ordinary, reform Jewish mind, ends all argument. The head of the Kuhn-Loeb Company, the Jewish Mzcenas, the American Rothschild, the liberal and wise philanthropist, has declared Zionism a dream! Shall the ordinary merchants and brokers and provincial members of the Jewish Reform Church venture an opinion after he has ennken ?

u ee But in the domain of historical precedents, in the face of vital issues that cannot be settled as easily as one balances his accounts every six months, with a problem that affects a whole people’'s future—in the presence of which the staving off of an immigration bill is a mere bagatelle—Mr. Schiff’s opinion loses its authority and must bear the scrutiny of impartial review, and his conclusions, also, must tallv wıth the known facts.

In essence, the criticism of Mr. Schiff’s view is that it is based on its narrowness. Will the larger question of anti-Semitism in Germany and Austria also be settled by the Industrial Removal Office and the Galveston scheme? Arc the five million Russian Jews to have their future made less of a dream by the Removal Office’? Has the Jewish question, in short, concentrated only at the port of New York, and have Kishineff, Roumania, Lueger, the British Aliens bill, etc., been erased from the pages of modern Jewish history, leaving no traces behind them?

It is an American Jewish problem. Mr. Schiff sees and thinks he solves. But even dispersion means reconcentration at some future time. Will the Jews of America throw off only those customs that are repugnant to modern conventions, and will their life express itself only in a religious form? The Yiddish literature, the Yiddish theatre, irreligion, nationalistic socialism among the Jews —cannot these also be scattered and made ineffective? Ghettoism is not confined to New York, nor is it altogether dependent upon numbers.

In short, it may be said without levity, literally, that Mr. Schiff has discussed the Jewish