THE COMMENTATOR
WONDERFUL DISCOVERY
“The Journal and Messenger makes the startling announcement that the editor of the Israelite is a Jew. We are discovered at last.” —_ Amoriran Ierarliie Arnpnst 1.
A good rule is, never believe all you see in the newspapers. From the accounts which the Israelite gives of Zionism, the Journal and Messenger announcement is actually required. The discovery is indeed startling.
WHAT IS THE MISSION?
"Let the Zionist ridicule the mission-idea of the Jew, he will one day wake up to learn that the laugh is on the other side."—TOBIAS SHANFARBER, Israelite.
WE have no quarrel with the Mission idea, per se, but with the kind of mission. We do believe it is our mission to re-establish the Jewish Nation on its ancient territory. We are mission Jews, too, but we don’t believe in a mission that does not square with good sense. The mission to be scattered and to be constantly striving to remedy the evils of our scattered condition, all the while holding up the banner of a propaganda which we cannot actualize and which if we could would not be acceptable to those among whom we are to make propaganda—is something we leave to “dreamers’ We are not spiritual monists.
THE COHN Case.
“The supporters of Rabbi Dr. Cohn, who failed to secure an abrogation of the decision of the communal authorities involving his dismissal, have resolved to found an independent congregation, and to place Dr. Cohn at its head.”— Jewish Chronicle (Lonpon).
THE attempt to read Zionism out of Judaism, which has technically succeeded here in America, will win but a temporary victory. In the Berlin case it has created a congregation which is avowedly Zionistic. In America it will create a determined minority in the reform camp, wihch will grow and eventu-
ally so re-make the reform program that its historians will soon find themselves in the position of outsiders. In the words of Dr. Schoessinger, "Reform Judaism will be Zionistic or not be at all."
DUPLICATING JEWISH HISTORY.
Parıs, August 21.—Very few persons are in Paris just now against their will, but such is the position of Dr. Emil G. Hirsch, of Chicago. Dr. Hirsch came from Chicago to make a special endeavor on behali of Russian Jews, but was turned back when he reached the Russian frontier. He returned to Paris, and is now at the Grand Hotel debating what next to do.—N. Y. Herald CABLE.
What sort of an endeavor did Dr. Emil G. Hirsch expect to make? What could any sane man expect to do in Russia, a foreigner and a Jew to boot? This is another instance of a cheap play to the galleries, by which the Jewish position is made ridiculous. Dr. Hirsch should have been a little more original; surely he cannot afford to be an imitator of Dr. Joseph Krauskopf, continuous publisher of sermons.
WHY DOESN'T HE WEAR A ZIONIST BUTTON
"Of course, it is hardly to be expected that the leaders of political Zionism will frankly acknowledge that the beginning of the end has come. . . Once let them abrogate entirely the notion of national rehabilitation and pledge allegiance to the purely philanthropic undertaking. . . and the Jews of the world will join hands with them.—Rabbi Leo M. Franklin, in THE REFORM ADVOCATE."
BEING one of the Jews of this world, and having decided that the last Congress effectually dealt the death-blow to political Zionism, why is Rabbi Franklin reluctant to send in his shekel, and wear the button of practical Zionism?
