The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 2 · August 1907
90printed page
scan 49 of 60
THE MACCABAEAN.
90

indifference of the Jewish public, and the support given it does not permit the employment of journalists to cover all the news for Jewish interest, not to say of a Zionistic interest.

Owing, however, to a development in American Jewish life of large importance, this branch of the Publication Committee's work was not required during the latter part of the winter and the early spring. The controversy arising out of the forced resignation of three Zionist professors from the Hebrew Union College filled the Jewish press with the Zionist issue, and your Committee sat back in its easy chair and let things take their normal course, occasionally obtaining wider publicity for certain contributions to the controversy, but forcing nothing upon the publishers.

During the year the following pamphlets were published and distributed:

ZIONISM, Its History and Aims, by Max Nordau5,000
ZIONISM, A Statement, by Solomon Schechter3,000
ZIONISM AND REFORM JUDAISM, by Max Schloessinger3,000
TEN YEARS OF ZIONISM, Yiddish and English10,000
THE PINKAS, in Yiddish3,000
SCHECHTER'S ZIONISM, in Yiddish1,500

In addition, several leaflets were gotten out for the Palestine Committee, and National Fund leaflets and slips were also printed. Copies of our publication were sent to Zionist societies, to prominent Jews in this country, to members of the American Jewish Committee, and to members of Congress.

In addition, the Publication Committee has been consulted in the publication of various pamphlets by THE MACCABAEAN Publishing Co. It was also instrumental in securing publicity in the Jewish press for a number of articles bearing on Zionism.

It is to be regretted that Zionists do not utilize the literary productions of the movement in their propaganda. We have provided catalogues of works of interest to Zionism, and have had them distributed by THE MACCA-BAEAN, but it is evident, from the reports sub-

mitted by THE MACCABAEAN and the Federation office, that Zionist societies do not place much reliance upon the value of literature for propaganda. This is an error, for the literature we distribute, if it be good, abides, while the mass meetings we arrange at large cost, pass away and soon are forgotten. We suggest that our Zionists make an effort to distribute the literature we have brought out in the English language under such adverse circumstances.

It will be noticed that the greater part of our publications are not historical or belletristic, but polemic in their purpose. This it was impossible to avoid, for the past year has been one of controversy, and controversy especially with the non-Zionist Jews. The reform issue, which presented important manifestations in the elements opposing Zionism, was one we could not avoid, and that had to be fought as long as the anti-Zionist reformers held to their unadulterated mission theory and their unqualified opposition to Zionism. We are of the opinion that that controversy may now be left to take care of itself.

We have before us but one other question to settle to the satisfaction of American Jews, which is, the problems involved in the consideration of Zionism and American patriotism. A large amount of superfluous and timid, almost cowardly, talk has been indulged in by Zionists and non-Zionists on this important question, and it is of great importance that a careful study be made of the problem stated with a view to setting, frankly, and without fear, the principles therein involved. Your committee therefore recommends that it become the sense of this Convention that a pamphlet or book be prepared covering the subject, from an American point of view for American Jews.

With the recommended disposition of this subject, it is advisable, in the opinion of your Committee, that less polemic literature be issued by the Federation and that more attention be paid to subjects of a belletristic or historical nature. Zionism does not win adherents by controversy. Controversy merely intensifies preconceived ideas, and solidifies opposition. Zionism must appeal to the Jews whose minds