our movement has made should have brought out more actively than ever before all the forces of our opponents. It is true that the opposition reduced itself to a mis-statement of our aims, to vituperation and defamation, to aspersions upon our fidelity to Judaism on the one hand and our loyalty to this country on the other. Secure in our own position, we did not feel ourselves called upon to enter the arena of polemics. With patience we listened over and over again to the arguments which our German brethren evolved in the first half of the ninetcenth century, when,’ with the first breath of intoxicating liberty, they felt constrained to construct new theories of Judaism and even to alter the ancient liturgy. We can appreciate their position without sharing their views, for the dread of the loss of their cherished freudom was overwhelming. Subsequent efforts at the dissection of Judaism, and fruitless attempts to reduce it here and take off there, have produced a perfect babel of views as to what Judaism is, and how little of Judaism is still Judaism, until their Judaism was no longer a living force, but a lifeless wreck.
Judaism is the ideal of life evolved by the Jew, based upon historic memories and reaching out into the distant future and the expression of this ideal in our life, individual ‚and communal. Judaism is a living whole, which cannot be cut into pieces without its .destruction. It is idle to speak of a national, racial or religious Judaism. In the Jew these tendencies are so interwoven that they cannot be separated without leaving the individual a spiritual cripple.
Zionism is no new discovery. It is the ‚expression of our confidence in the Jewish ideals and the effort to help bring about their realization. But, in sweet-sounding words, we are told that through all the centuries our -people have been in error: the ideal of once -more attaining national dignity and independence must be buried, the hope of again taking a position of beneficient influence among the nations is a delusion. For, to be American, we are told, requires that we must divest nurselves of our all. To those who thus :ridress us, we may answer that America
requires nothing of the kind. There is a provision in our Constitution which guarantees religious freedom, and no American has for a moment questioned the right of the Jews to their hopes—nay, on the contrary, many share them with us. It has remained for the Jew to call his brother traitor. Let them well weigh the words they have spoken; the argument, followed to its logical conclusion, brands with treachery every pious Jew who daily prays, over and over again, for the return to Zion. No, America is not intolerant! It is from among our own people—with shame be it said!—from a people that has suffered an unending martyrdom of religious persecution, that has learnt to know intolerance in all its forms; it is from among this people that the men have risen who now are proving themselves masters in the art of excommunication. And these very men have for years praised themselves for their liberality of thought! These are the men who tell us that the mission of the Jew is to live among the Gentiles to teach them justicee We have reason to be grateful that their offers of gratuitous instruction have not been accepted. Let us put an end to this discussion concerning the patriotism of the Zionist, or, more properly stated, the patriotism of the Jew. The most pious believers in the Restoration, the most ardent workers for its consummation, have shown themselves in no way inferior to other Americans in devotion to this country; they have ever been among the foremost in responding to their obligations, and none have been more truly solicitous for its welfare, prosperity. and honor than they!
But I should discuss a most important point in this discussion, were I not to call attention to the underlying reason of many of the denunciations which have been hurled against our movement. Not that it is usually mentioned; on the contrary, it is avoided. Only here and there does it make its appearance. I refer to anti-Semitism, or, rather, the fear of anti-Semitism. Have we not been told that we are responsible for its growth? Has not a Jewish weekly had the lying audacity to make this statement in its editorial column? But even this has not disturbed us,
