The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 2 · August 1907
68printed page
scan 28 of 60

ment of an Agrarian Bank, was read. See Appendix I.

Speeches were made by Mr. Isaacs, Mr. Fromenson, and Dr. Wortsmann, all in favor of immediate practical work. Mr. Abel saw no opposition between the two policies. Practical work, in his opinion, was political.

Mr. Lipsky offered an amendment to insert in the report, "That by industrial and agricultural work is meant work in Palestine by individuals and societies inspired by Zionistic propaganda and the Zionist organization, but not directly carried on by the Actions Committee or with its general funds."

The amendment caused much excitement. Several delegates thought it in effect a reversal of the meaning of the report. There were speeches by Schechter, Jackson, Gordon, and J. Friedlander. Prof. Schechter, who was a member of the committee, said the report was a compromise, and, although he had been opposed to some points in it. he had signed it because he believed it was the most practicable under the circumstances. He thought it was time to leave off making big phrases. He thought the old way of praying for a return to Zion was better than the vague talk so often heard. Praying was, in its way, something practical. “Do something!”

Mr. Abel offered an amendment which was practically to the same effect as Mr. Lipsky’s. Mr. Tierkel also offered an amendment.

The vote resulted in the defeat of Mr. Lipsky’s amendment and the adoption of Mr. Abel’s and Mr. Tierkel’s. The first, second and fourth propositions of the report were adopted. The third was withdrawn. The committee was instructed to re-draft its report and incorporate therein the amendments that had been adopted. The report was finally brought in again Tuesday afternoon. A motion was then made by Mr. Lipsky to omit all but the propositions that had been voted on. The motion was defeated. It was moved and adopted to transmit the report to the American delegates to the Eighth Congress. The report, as amended and adopted, follows:

Your Committee appointed to consider the correspondence from Dr. Max Nordau,

Herr Ussischkin, and others, begs leave to report as follows:

We have carefully deliberated on the propositions contained in the above letters, representing the two different lines of policy which for a period of two years, dating from the last Basle Congress, has divided the Zionist body; and we advise this Convention to give its approval to recommendations contained in the following paragraph of Herr Ussischkin's letter:

I. The facilitating and quickening of the transfer of Palestinian soil, with all the means and through the organizations at our command, with the National Fund at their head. To this end, we favor the establishment of an agrarian bank, which shall exist for the purpose of helping Jewish farmers to purchase, acquire and develop land.

II. The development of trade and industry in Palestine and Syria, and the steady attraction of private Jewish capital for these purposes under the guidance of the Jewish Colonial Trust and the Anglo-Palestine Bank.

III. The obtaining of concessions from the Turkish Government advantageous to the objects of our cause.

IV. The cultural elevation of the Jews in Palestine.

We are of opinion that the support to be drawn from the Zionist institutions for the development of Palestine shall be of a nature that will not cripple them from serving the higher purposes originally assigned to them.

We look upon the adoption of this program and its energetic pursuit, not as a supersession of the original plan by which our object was sought to be attained, but as a different and perhaps more practical method for gaining it. The situation demands a compromise, a compromise which shall embody the main features of both the political and practical work ideas, fusing and re-shaping them into a more plastic and feasible form. This policy has been aptly called the "tunnel" policy, the policy which seeks the achievement of our objects by prosecuting work at both ends of the mountain. In admitting the claims of practical