The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 2 · August 1907
26scan
of 60
64-65-66
THE MACCABARAN.

been opposed to the specialism represented by Reform Judaism. Judaism was broader than religion or theology in the Christian sense. Mr. Isaacs said:

Whenever a great man who has made a deep and lasting impression on his time is taken from our midst, it is natural that those who have worked along with him and sympathized with him should mourn him most. The late Dr. Lewis Naphtali Dembitz was a man of many sides. As an attorney with a national reputation, he has been lamented by his legal friends and ad- mirerss. As a man of affairs, he has been eulogized by the public press. As a Jewish scholar, he has been accorded a fitting tribute by all the learned Jewish bodies of the land. As a Zionist, he cannot be forgotten by the Zionists. Our sense of bereavement is strong.

To us he was, above all, the Jew who, while thoroughly absorbing the best that is in American life and contributing something to it, never lost his Jewish patriotism. In him the most admirable type of Jewish sentiment found one of its finest expressions in America, for he was interested heart and soul in Judaism for its own sake. He was the Jewish lay scholar. He was proud of this title, and justly so, for in an age when the tendency raging about the ears of his contemporaries was toward that pernicious kind of specialization in Judaism that has almost deprived the layman of his Jewishness, that has limited the concept of Judaism itself to a theological system or a reli- ligion in the restricted (Christian) sense, that has cramped even that religion into a few lyrical formalities—while this tendency was raging most fiercely, he, almost alone among his associates, stood out and declared by his actions that Judaism is all of life, not an insignificant, formal part of it. And now that this wild tendency has exhausted itself, and Jews are assembled for the specific purpose of working out the non-religious elements in Judaism, we can see that Dr. Dembitz, the conservative Jew, the Nationalist, the Zionist, was right. He was a true prophet in Israel; and though we are not fortunate enough to have him with

us still, it is a consolation that he was spared long enough to communicate that spirit and interpretation of Judaism which was all but universal in his youth to the young people of a second and a third generation. Young people admired him. They always surrounded him, and he inspired them as few Jews of this day have been able to do. It is a consolation that Dr. Dembitz was spared long enough to realize that his work bore fruit, that the impression of such men as he on our times had not been lost, and this is a blessing granted to but few. And the best tribute that we can pay to his memory is to let his example exert its full influence on our lives.

At the conclusion of Mr. Isaac's remarks, Mr. Fromenson, Chairman of the Propaganda and Organization Committee, read his report. See Appendix II.

The report of the Propaganda and Organization Committee occasioned the liveliest discussion of the Convention. The burden of criticism was that the report was no report at all, and that the Chairman of this committee might as well have followed the example of the other chairmen, who had said frankly, nothing had been done. The management of Schmaryahu Lewin's tour was especially the object of attack. Some of the societies had lost money because dates had not been kept on that tour. The managers of the tour were accused of truckling to men in positions of influence or possessed of wealth, while ignoring the true interests of the cause.

Dr. H. Epstein, one of the speakers, said nothing indeed had been done, but the fault lay rather in the lack of means than in the mismanagement of the committee. A press was needed, and frequent meetings of the committees were desirable. The committees should work together and not in isolation.

Dr. Wortsman was of the opinion that Mr. Fromenson was being made a scapegoat, and that the real fault was with the system. By the system, he meant what he called "Koved Zionismus,"—Zionism that is solicitous about honoring well-known persons. This should cease and Zionism should become more democratic.