The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 1 · July 1907
4printed page
scan 8 of 46
Facsimile · scan 8 of 46
Scan of p. 4
Text · transcribed from the scan

when captured, escaped a death by torture by persuading the Caliph that if his head were struck off at a blow, it would at once come on again. The Caliph must have felt disappointed.

The moral which the astute political genius of a Disraeli embodied in this tale of Alroy may not come amiss to Zionists. He shows us this man, rousing the dormant powers of his countrymen to wonderful victories, but balked in the course of his triumphs by a stubborn failure to recognize that he was followed by this host, not to create a Semitic nationality at any indifferent spot in Asia Minor, not to help him build a world empire of selfish ambition, but to soothe the yearning of the Jews to dwell once more in Jerusalem, by Mount Zion. It was a spiritual aspiration that animated them, not a political. So to-day it may be well to accept the insight of a Disraeli into the motives that would move the Jews to concerted action, and lay aside once for all the thought of a Jewish state that is not firmly builded on the traditions. Either Zion or nothing. For there is no Mount of Olives in Africa; that is the lodestar that must guide every Jewish movement that would not invite the fate of Alroy. Disraeli, the Prime Minister, has seen more clearly than Zangwill, the pessimistic humorist. Again one important phase of true Zionism may be drawn from this story of Disraeli’s. The longing for a home in Zion must proceed from an intense emotional love of what is Jewish, and not from any need for a refuge. These men who followed Alroy were fairly well off; and Disraeli himself is an example in point. The Prime Minister of England needed no refuge; but his love for Jerusalem was deep and intense. We may well imagine that often in the midst of his struggles and triumphs, his heart turned to those scenes he depicts in “Alroy.” In conclusion I would quote a passage from “Alroy” that will indicate better than any words of comment how Disraeli felt. When Jabaster, the high priest, learns that Alroy intends to

commit the sin of Solomon and marry a foreign princess, he comes in dismay to his king. The latter angrily asks him what he would have him do more than he had already done. Jabaster replies:

"You ask me what I wish: my answer is, the Land of Promise. You ask me what I wish: my answer is, Jerusalem. You ask me what I wish: my answer is, the Temple, all we have forfeited, all we have yearned after, all for which we have fought, our beauteous country, our holy creed, our simple manners, and our ancient customs."

This may sound over rhetorical, but the rhetoric of men like Disraeli is inherent and sincere. At any rate the passage is the voice of modern Zionism.

There is a verse in Isaiah that runs: “One shall say I am the Lord’s; and another shall call himself by the name of Jacob; and another shall subscribe with his name unto the Lord, and surname himself by the name of Israel.” What a fortunate thing ıf Zionism could indeed have for its leader to-day this man who had truly “surnamed himself by the name of Israel” though not “unto the Lord!” And after all it is in some such aspiration that Disraeli’s chief interest for Zionism must consist. We are not concerned so much with ‚what he actually said or did that was Zionistic in tenor, as with what a man with ideals and force like his would be able to do for Zionism to-day. But the nation that produced once this remarkable genius may hope when the need truly arises that another wi.l not fail. Such a man will hew a state out of the disunited Jews, just as once Disraeli hewed a state out of the unwilling aristocrats of Britain; he will guide us in the paths of nations, just as Disraeli guided England to its larger destiny; and he will conquer difhculties such as Disraeli conquered, not for an alien but for his own; not for those that despise but for those that love; for Judea not England. Then the lost Pleiad will have been found — when the stars are in due conjunction.