The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 1 · July 1907
8printed page
scan 12 of 46

onism is in character defensive, conservative, therefore it is “unavoidably reactionary.” Bickerman will admit, that when it is threatened with danger, a good thing becomes necessary to “safeguard” it. Another not less ridiculous statement is made by Bickerman, that there is nothing cheaper than to become a Zionist: all that is necessary is to declare oneself a Zionist and pay the dues; no work is required, and no acceptance of any ideas is demanded of any one; it is clear proof that Zionism is one thing and life quite another thing. Is ıt possible that Bickerman is not aware that in all countries there is nothing cheaper than to enlist oneself in any party— all that is suflicient is to state etc., etc, and for this no action of any kind is demanded. Bickerman expresses his singularity also by other statements, such as: “A people spending its strength for the creation of a new state would unavoidably slacken in its culture, a truth supported by universal history. The Zionists ask us to leave, in order to begin anew in a new place, to submit several generations to suffering in order to reach only some centuries later that condition of culture in which we are now.” To this we can reply that all the well-read people know that just those who created new states, for instance the North American and Australian immigrants, made the greatest advances in a very short time and that they are now far ahead of old Europe, in cultural conditions.

Bickerman concludes with a statement that the realization of Zionism would destroy Jewry,—the Jewish race and the Jewish culture; that in the process of state-formation an assimilation of races will occur. To this we can reply to Bickerman that the Zionists do not expect the state-formation by Jews plus also some other nationalities, but expect that the Jews will succeed in gaining the cession of Palestine to the Jews for the creation of a Jewish state. No one will come to our assistance (perhaps there some will come to disturb, but that is a different question), and there will be no one to assimilate with. The handful of native Arabians will display just as much willingness to assimilate with us as

we have with the dominating nations in Goluth.

Having in a short manner examined the direct and indirect methods of criticizing our movement, we notice how contemptuously our critics treat a great movement and criticize it in an off-hand way. They only display a lack of seriousness and deep thought toward a movement in which take part tens of thousands of people with definite, practical ideas. One can agree or disagree, co-operate or Oppose; only a man with a superficial mind can content himself with a shrug of the shoulders, with lamentations that the movement is a reactive one, or, what is least likely, to proclaim it a Utopia,—a miserable word, taken from the dictionary of a coward, a word unbecoming a serious man to repeat. Many things which but half a century ago were called Utopian are now conquering the world. In conclusion, we will ask our critics to regard our movement with a deeper consideration; they will render thus a service of a greater degree to themselves than to us. In what concerns us, every expression of sympathy from outside ıs to us very agreeable and precious, but one need not think that Zionism is wandering on its road with outstretched arms, begging strangers for a sıft of sympathy.

We are greatly aware that our salvation is not in the sympathy of an outside people but it must come through our own self-help. A cheerful word from a stranger does not throw us into ecstacy, nor a disapproval of a stranger into confusion and thus weaken our determination. We go on our way, because we are impelled by an insurmountable imperative; in the strength of this imperative is our cheer and vitality. We go on straight forward our own way, not awaiting praises and approvals of our friends, nor from those who wish to remain strangers.

In the restoration of the fatherland of Garibaldi, the Italian motto was “PItaly fara de se—“Italy will help itself,” and with this the Italians gained their victory. We too will restore our fatherland by self-help and rejuvenate our people by the language of the Torah “ivirt be writ.”