everything and do not surrender themselves. This is, Bickerman thinks, an obstinate and systematic deviation from the course of least resistance. How can he explain this enigma? To ourselves we explain it very simply. The masses, for the satisfaction of their dominant needs, direct themselves along a course of least resistance, and it is impossible for them to divert from this course. Evidently, it is not for Bickerman to know what needs are more supreme for the masses and which course appears to offer the least resistance. If the Jews suffer so many centuries for.their Judaism, it means that they have the predominant need to preserve their Judaism; and to renounce this need would be immeasurably more difficult than the renunciation of a free satisfaction of this daily want. Just as well as the Puritans, finding themselves in a position similar to the Jews, considered that the course of least resistance was not in a struggle in their place, but in a mass emigration; so the Jews who have suffered more than the Puritans suffered and have lost all hope of any possibility to live humanely in the Goluth, and find in Zionism the course of least resistance.
The third objection of Bickerman to Zionism is that it is a purely negative movement, called out only by Anti-Semitism. The Zionist idea is but the result of offended self-love and a panic fear at time of calamities. To protect themselves from these calamities it would be sufficient to adopt Bickerman's course, the course of least resistance, i. e., to renounce that which causes these calamities—"the Semitism." This would be a plain flight, a perfectly negative movement, caused by persecution. If, instead of accepting apostasy, we call on each other for deeds, which appear difficult, it is clear that we do not so much escape persecutions as we preserve something positive. We do not escape helter-skelter from persecution, but we save something that is precious to us, some flower, which we wish to plant again and rear on its native soil. This is the principal impulse of Zionism.
Between Zionism and Anti-Semitism there is "a spiritual relation," says Bickerman. In its fundamental premises Zionism is based on the principles of Anti-Semitism. Max Nordau
says that Anti-Semitism will continue to exist in the distant future, because it is in the closest relation with the fundamental qualitieg of human thought and sentiment. It is peculiar that in this regard Kautsky agrees with Max Nordau, for he states that Anti-Semitism will disappear only when Semites will disappear. Bickerman has a wrong idea in believing that Zionism is based only upon Anti-Semitism. Our movement is yet in its infancy and is waiting for its scientific theorist, but we are assured that in the scheme of theoretic elements of Zionism, Anti-Semitism and Judennot will occupy a very modest place. The theory will probably be such: each racial group naturally tends to a complete independence in all forms and processes of its cultural activity of life; therefore, the prospective of assimilation excites in this group a resistance, a struggle for national self-preservation; after the loss of the natural isolating means, the national territory, this impulse of national self-preservation compelled the Jews to fence themselves in artifcially by religious dogmatism, in order to preserve themselves from an amalgamation with other people. The new social economic conditions tore down the Ghetto walls; with it, the artificial fence, the religious dogmatism, which preserved Judaism from dissolution in strange lands, began to crumble. The natural impulse of national self-preservation incites Jewry to strive for a re-establishment of the natural isolating means, i. e., uational autonomous territory in order to 'secure forever for the national individuality the complete culture in all its. forms of activity. Anti-Semitism will be considered by the theorist only a minor detail
As an argument for Zionist agitation the use of Anti-Semitism, especially “raised to a principle,” is of course very useful and convenient. There is no doubt that Anti-Semitism assists greatly to reawaken the national sentiment, but never to create it. The role of Anti-Semitism resembles that of a flea; the sleeping being aroused by the flea-bite betakes himself to his productive work not for the sake of the unclean insect, but out of the instinct of life and labor which is inborn in him.
Further, Bickerman states, that because Zi-
