The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 1 · July 1907
6printed page
scan 10 of 46
6
THE MACCABAEAN.

Men learn things by observation. Suppose the first immigrants did not even suspect that of their immigration would arise a new and independent government, but we already know that a state was formed by the first immigrants, and if we now wish to emigrate, we can also consider or at least hope that our emigration will lead to the same results and actively prepare ourselves for it. Must we be overtaken by failure? Is there any logical reasoning in this? What is the difference between Zionism and any other already formed mass emigration, which leads to the foundation of new states? Zionism contains two fundamental principles: first, the settlement of the Jewish people on one territory; second, autonomy, i. e., guaranty of self-government. These were the leading principles in all historical mass emigrations, and are unchanged at the present days; these were the causes of the creation of the states.

The Pilgrim Fathers emigrating to North America did not go there in order to submit themselves to rulers of the wild inhabitants. They had in view a very sound guaranty of self-government—their guns and their knives. The same can be said of the great migrations of people. The Huns, nearing Europe, thought very little of becoming alien subjects, but, on the contrary, they depended on their guns for a complete guaranty of their autonomy. In those times no migration occurred without this naturally presupposed guaranty of self-government. Zionism,: having for its object a territory and autonomy, does not bring out anything new. It only replaces the sword form of guaranty by a treaty form, which strongly corresponds to our modern times. In general all forms of sword guaranty become now obsolete and are being replaced by treaties. Duel, i. e,, club guaranty of inviolability of the individual, and war, i. e., sword guaranty of inviolability of an aggregate, gradually give away their significance to treaty institutions, to arbitration courts. The Huns migrating to Europe guaranteed for themselves their autonomy, and we, emigrating to Palestine, must also guarantee it; but their guaranty corresponding to those times was represented by the right of the sword, and ours, corresponding to the spirit of our times, must be

represented in a form of a treaty charter. This is just as natural and just as little changes the substance of the object as for instance that the Huns emigrated on horseback or Kibitka (Tilt-carts) and we will go on modern steamers.

The same logic prevails in Bickerman’s consideration, that Zionism proposes a movement along a course of the greatest resistance. “People everywhere and at all times acted under the pressure of immediate wants and necessities and their actions, as all actions of any force in nature, directed themselves along a course of least resistance” According to Bickerman the course of least resistance in this case is for the Jews to strive for their rights here, on the place, for it is much easier and simpler here, where one is acclımatized, than to cross the ocean and to meet with the greatest difficulties. At the same time Bickerman explains that the cause of the emigration of Pilgrim Fathers was, that “the Puritans were seeking for freedom of conscience and quiet; both of these at that time could be found only across the ocean; therefore, they crossed the ocean.” That sounds strange. According to Bickerman’s theory, it would be much easier and simpler for the Puritans to remain on their old places and struggle for their rights there, than to cross the ocean to the redskins.. Bickerman must admit that th: action of the Puritans was a clear deviation from the course of least resistance. Still more severely must Bickerman regard the fact of a two-thousand-year preservation of Jewish nationality . . . The Jews were driven from place to place and exposed to most excessive persecutions, only because they were Jews. Evidently, then, their immediate wants and necessities “systematically suffered for their adherence to Judaism.” Where was the course of least resistance for a way out of this condition? From Bickerman’s point of view it should be in apostasy. Nowadays, it is true, even an apostate is considered to be a Jew, but in Spain apostates were encouraged and married Spanish maidens.

The easiest and simplest of all means appears —to cease to be Jews, and the "immediate wants and necessities" would be satisfied. Instead of this we see that the Jews sacrifice