The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 6 · June 1907
208printed page
scan 8 of 54
Facsimile · scan 8 of 54
Scan of p. 208
Text · transcribed from the scan

certain truth to mankind, it cannot remain exclusive. Truth is no respecter of persons, nor even of races. To lead the way in the advancement of civilization is to identify oneself with human society in its solidarity, in its community of interest. I propose, therefore, to ask how Judaism may be made to live through being incorporated into civilization; how it may season the whole without losing its own savour.

Let me say at the outset that that which has most impressed me in contemplating the general history of Judaism is its dualism. There are two Judaisms, the inner and the outer; the ideas which have moved and sustained these people, for which they have lived and suffered, and those traits which have marked the Jews in the life of the world. In other words, there is a great difference, amounting almost to irrelevancy, between that which the Jew is to himself and that which he is to others. I propose, therefore, to consider first the inner side of Judaism, second the outer side of Judaism, and then certain conclusions which this analysis suggests to me.

L

I realize that any enumeration of racial ideas under separate heads cannot fail to be dry, pedantic and inadequate, but some sort of classification is necessary, and I trust that the following arrangement will serve to cover the ground. I shall distinguish three ideas: First, the vital importance of virtue; second, the perfection of discipline; and third, the moral league with God.

1. The Vital Importance of Virtue The Jew of all times has recognized, as no sober moralist can fail to do, that the true significance of virtue lies in its power to conserve and promote life. There is a constant tendency for morals to become so stereotyped and conventionalized as to entirely lose this significance. Those of you who are familiar with philosophical literature will perhaps remember a dispute between Thrasymachus and Socrates in the first book of Plato’s Republic. Thrasymachus, who is a somewhat exaggerated representation of the sophistical teaching of the time, has discovered what he believes to be the uselessness of morals. The enlightened man, he says, will dismiss them altogether and make his way directly to his goal without scru-

ples or principles. He may find morals a convenient pretext, but will never adopt them for his own guidance. Thrasymachus illustrates his thesis by pointing out the great advantage enjoyed by the opportunist over the man who is embarrassed by allegiance to maxims and ideals. But Socrates, on the other hand, meets the sophist on his own ground and establishes morals as nothing more nor less than the very method of conduct or rational action. There is no such thing as success without knowing what you want and proceeding steadfastly and systematically to realize it; and it is because human nature is what it is and social relations are what they are that temperance, justice and the other virtues have proved themselves to be the only sure means of gaining any really important end. This is fundamental, ethical truth, and the Jews have never failed instinctively to appreciate it. Their remarkable vitality is doubtless due in part to physical characteristics, but is also to be explained bv their practical recognition in all ages that the way of morals is the way of life To the Jews, then, we look for the consistent practice of the fundamental virtues, of those modes of conduct which condition physical health, livelihood and social stability. They understood the importance of dietetics, of the exercising of care in the selection and preparation of food long before the rise of physiological chemistry. As is well known, they are instinctively and habitually temperate. Their comparatively low death rate under most adverse economic conditions is due largely to an almost total absence of alcoholism and its attendant evils. Again, the Jews understand the great vital importance of the institution of the family. They have sanctified it by ritual, and have made it the centre of the firmest and most intimate relationships. Thus they have protected their women, and cared for their children. Again, they have always recognized the practical importance of education; and though they have for the most part been entirely dependent upon their own traditions and have lacked resources and facilities, they have never failed to praise and to practice the early cultivation of the mind and will. Finally, we may note the success of the Jews in all matters affecting livelihood. The virtue of thrift, upon which the