The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 6 · June 1907
240printed page
scan 40 of 54
240
THE MACCABAEAN.

THE MACCABEN

A Monthly Magazine under the supervision of the Federation of American Zionists. Edited by LOUIS LIPARY

EDITORIAL PAGES

June, 1907

THE ETHICS OF THE H. U. C. CONTROVERSY.

The ethical side of the dealings of the Hebrew Union College, with its Zionist professors and students has not been touched upon. It seems to have been granted that theology and ethics have nothing in common. Even the theological opponents of the H. U. C. have judiciously refrained from commenting on the moral right of the College to insist on the incompatibility of Zionism and Reform Judaism after its students had entered the institution with an implied agreement that there was nothing in Jewish theology—not even in that tenuous variety known as reform Judaism—at variance with Zionism.

A theological seminary usually offers its students a creed and a curriculum; its dogmas are clearly stated. If the student approves of the creed and of the curriculum, he matriculates. If he had known that the advent of a president meant the adoption of a new dogma, without a synodial agreement, and in contradiction to that particular theology as he had understood it, he would have thought twice before entering.

Only with the coming of Dr. K. Kohler were students made aware of the claim that Reform Judaism was irrevocably opposed to Zionism. This novel view was presented to the students not without lack of scholarly decorum, not without weaknesses of temper, by the gentleman who, as the present head of the College, has now gone to Chicago to fulminate his imprecations against Zionism, and thus officially to excommunicate the national movement.

Theretofore, and under the guidance of Dr. I. M. Wise—whom Dr. Kohler and his sainted brother-in-law fought tooth and nail while he was alive—the rabbinical student believed he was free to consider Zionism on its merits as

one of the phases of Jewish development. He may have taken his inspiration from recognized reform rabbis, who were not backward in announcing their Zionistic affiliations. They may have arrived at the conclusion, that any thing that strengthened Jewish consciousness, brought the Jews closer together, raised their pride, and cleared their future for them, was welcome to reform Judaism.

With these thoughts, he may have entered the Hebrew Union College, with mature de- hiberation, and dedicated himself to the professional career of a rabbi to the exclusion of all other pursuits. Then Dr. Kohler took the helm at the College and he was made to discover his error. The tolerance of Dr, Wise was followed by a tempestuous, “Kohleric,” bigoted administration, lacking dignity, lacking. discipline, and lacking all those characteristics one associates with a theological semin- fary. Finally, after a period of malevolent !persecution and most un-Jewish bigotry, three professors were deposed as members of the faculty, and Zionism was oflicially anathema in the College. The Central Conference of ı American Rabbis had not acted, the Union of American Hebrew Congregations had not acted, but Dr. Kohler, backed by gentlemen who, obviously, are not authorities in matters of theology, alone took the responsibility of this rash act.

The Zionist student at the Hebrew Union College has been wronged by his alma mater. He has been deceived by his teachers. He has been enveigled into a theological seminary which had not disclosed its creed, and which now cruelly flaunts a sophistical, intemperate interpretation of Jewish life as the creed which he is supposed to have endorsed. He cannot enter an orthodox seminary, because he is not orthodox in his views; he cannot remain in the reform seminary, because it has eliminated Zionism from its vocabulary, except to berate it.

We submit that the bland assurance of the Governors of the College that in their opinion their endorsement of Dr. Kohler's campaign of persecution was for the best, cannot be accepted, and that an explanation is owing the Jewish world for their betrayal of the confidence of the Zionist students of the College.