swers this question in an indirect way.
Assimilation, he writes, consists of two acts, negative and positive, one a renouncing surrender of individualizing traits, the other an acceptance of that, with which one assimilates. From what concerns the first, the negative act, it is evident that the whole course of history severely and inexorably destroys the Jewish individuality. The Jews drawn into the whirlpool of modern life, lose their specific garb, their traits, and little by little forsake the laws of ritualistic cleanliness, entirely renounce them, and even abandon the Sabbath.
All this only demonstrates a lack of familiarity with the question in the writer, It is not a proof yet, that the Jewish intellectual, having exchanged the skull cap for a hat, stuffed fish for caviar, and even the Sabbath, out of necessity, for Sunday, has become a cosmopolitan. On the contrary, it is this intellectual and not the orthodox Jew that makes the quality of the main kernel of the Jewish nationalism. .For instance, whoever is acquainted with the personality and teachings of Achad Haam, knows that Achad Haam, after discarding talmudic observances and even religious belief did not cease to consider himself a Jew. It is absurd to prove to the reader. that there is in Judaism something besides the code of Kashrus; but whose fault is it that it becomes necessary to insist on such abecedenarian truths. Isgoeff and Kautsky, before expressing their views, should have made :a study of what constitutes the Jewish culture and Jewish traditions. It is needless to ppint out what was written about Jewish culture and traditions by men of our own race, such as Lazarus, Darmstadter, or by the favorably inclined towards us Renan, Henry George, but for the sake of contrast we can refer to A recently published book, the author of -which, though observing a correct.tone, not in the least hides his antipathy to the Jews and Jewish ideals. In this book, “Esprit Juive,” the author, M. Muree, indicates some fundamental motives in the teachings of the prophets, and endeavors to. prove that these motiyes through many centuries manifest them- sektes-in the writing af Spinoda, Heine, Brandes; .Nordau, in’the:teachings of Marx and imtheactivitv of Disraeli.
These motives, in Muree's opinion, are: the rebellious hatred of every dogma, a hatred which compels the Jews to submit to a demolishing criticism of everything hallowed by tradition—the ideal of universal brotherhood (the ideal of cosmopolitanism of the prophets, as Muree expresses himself), the ideal, in the name of which all the Jews appear as the principal opponents of war and so on, and finally the aspiration to establish the kingdom of God on earth in contradistinction to the Aryan ideal of God's kingdom beyond the grave, impels the Jews to bring about social reformations. All these motives are highly unsympathetic to the author, who, with great vexation, remarks that these ideas have gained great popularity even among the Aryan masses.
_- Ziutad I De Ge 7 wv.wan eine - ) 2 2 0 2 ee? And er The Seventh and the Jubilee years, the principles of Sabbath rest, the social’ teachings of Amos, the ideals of Isaiah, of the peace of nations, finally the very cult of the Book, thanks to which until recently, there was not in Lith« uania an illiterate Jew at a time when in Western Europe the masses could not read in any‘ language, such apparentiy are our traditions. The critics tell us, that not only Jews but alt advanced people are now defending the lot of the poor and spreading knowledge. To this we can say, that the immemorial traditions of the Jewish race in any event are .neither: injurious nor inimical to universal progress. But our critics insist that before adapting: any of the advanced views, we must renqaunce the Jewish traditions, because the Jewish traditions are expressed in wearing of a breast-
- Such declarations are but: the result of ignorance Such a glaring phenomenon presents itself to our eyes; a struggle for twenty centuries by a small race without a country for its national individuality, a struggle ‚in which all the advantages that can be thought of are undisputably on the side of secession, and yet no secession took place. Kautsky and Isgoetf as materialistic historians should admit this surprisingly lasting historical fact. Evidently here works some powerful factor in the self-preservation of a group; and such & factor one cannot avoid dealing with; but our critics prefer to ignore a phenomenon which is. inadmissible to ignore, or they consider that the two thousand. year torturous martyrdom did not have back of it some great imperative, but that it was the result of misconception— human folly; now, the people have become wiser and have learned that there is nothing to fight for. This is very characteristic of the critics. "
[Mr. Shabotinsky concludes his review with a survey of the criticism of Bickerman. The articles concludes next month.]