The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 6 · June 1907
237printed page
scan 37 of 54

The Critics of Zionism

By V. Shabotinsky

(Continued from last month.)

II.

T: second critic, Uzakoff, pretends not to see any difference between the nationalism of an oppressed people, defending its independence, and the nationalism of a people which oppresses and imposes upon others its physiognomy—between self-defense and violencee.e He remarks that nationalism, including Zionism, is contrary and inimical to the ideals of honor and consicence, the principles of,solidarity and fraternity. Having observed the abuses of. nationalism, Uzakoff cannot understand that ennobling impulse of national self-preservation, which is so important and useful. Our aim is to secure the same rights which other people enjoy, not for the sake of carrying on plundering wars, but to live a quiet life according to our own national ideals, in peace and friendly collaboration with other nations. We assert with a stronger persistency that the preservation of nationalities in the interest of humanity, is an important problem; no sacrifice should be regretted for its realization.

III.

Isgoeff coincides with the opinion of Uzakoff but he differs in method. While Uzakoff invites us to renounce nationalism and become cosmopolitans and internationalists, Isgoeff, without any explanation, recommends to us (in Russia) Russification. To Isgoeff it is immaterial whether the French become German or the German become French, only that there should be at least one nationality less, and thus in the end we will become cosmopolitans without national distinctions. Such are the views held in common by Kautsky, Uzakoff and Isgoeff. As I have proven, there is no hope for a future disappearance of national differences, there is no scientific nor moral basis for it. What is most striking, even on first appearance, is the dissension of the critics

themselves on notions of ethnology, course of historical process, and ideal interests of humanity.

In the article of Isgoeff, besides the appeal for cosmopolitanism, there are particulars which cannot be left unanswered. Approving of territorialism, tolerating it on account of its harmlessness, he irrevocably condemns Palestinian Zionism, Cultural Zionism. Zionism as a romantic vision of regeneration of the ancient Jewish culture, is a reactionary and dangerous Utopia. First of all, we must point out a great inaccuracy; we do not have ın view the ancient Jewish Culture, but simply the Jewish, for we believe that in the spiritual creative genius of the Jews, from the prophets to our days, appeared one and the same fundamental ideal, of course changing the form and point of application in correspondence with the need of place and time; consequently, we desire not the restoration of ancient Jewish culture, but a broad development of Neo-Jewish, which is in close successive continuity with the old, older and ancient. To cure a sick adult man does not mean at all to resurrect the infant which that man was in the days of his infancy. This severe reference to the Jewish culture is evoked not because it is ancient, but because in this culture, as such, Isgoeff finds no positive values. There are reasons to believe that Isgoeff holds the same views as Kautsky. Deep and bold Jewish thinkers, he says, always accept the views of their time. This was possible only when they tore themselves away from the traditions of Judaism and put themselves on the level with the European cultural development. If Isgoeff would not consider the traditions of Judaism inconsistent with advanced views, he would not call the idea of a resurrection of Jewish culture a reactionary and pernicious Utopia. What do Isgoeff and Kautsky understand by Jewish traditions and culture? Kautsky does not explain himself, but Isgoeff an-