also by the untrue rumors and the false interpretations of my innocently given signature, wrote a letter on February 13 to the council of the community, in which I sought to annul my signature in order to make impossible, once for all, the false commentaries and to steer the whole affair into different waters, more just ones, for I hoped that I should finally be given a personal hearing by the representatives.
I at the same time made a proposal that the note of the director be submitted. I desired thereby to explain it sentence by sentence in writing in order to clear up the trend of the conversation and to suppress for the future unfounded interpretations. I received no reply to my letter. On February 19 I wrote again. The note was refused. On February 22 I asked for it again in sent. It was again refused. On the 25th I sent to me wardens and the representatives a memorandum in which I presented my point of view on the Jewish question and the opinions on which I and the director had differed. An account of the conversation itself was to follow this memorandum in connection with the director's note, the wording of which I still hoped to receive, as I stated in the introduction to the memorandum. But up to the present I have not received it. It was in the interview with the council of February 22, following my proposal, that I heard it read for the second and last time. I have imparted it above in the form that I then learned by heart. At this interview I tried again to enlighten the gentlemen of the council, not without result as it seemed to me then.
On the 28th of February the mixed committee met. I was officially informed by Herr Lilienthal that my suspension had been formally decided upon. I was then made to wait not less than six weeks. I still hoped that the representatives would give me a hearing and was sure that in a case of this kind no one would pass judgment without having heard me. Nevertheless, I was finally condemned, almost unanimously.
Half of the wardens and more than half of
the representatives have not heard me at all. Those that have heard me have, for the most part, done so unwillingly. I had to seek out most of them privately.
Finally on April 15, 1907, I received after manifold warning the notice that by vote of the community on March 21 and 29 it had been decided that thenceforth I was to officiate no more either as preacher or religious instructor. My salary would be paid me during the period of my contract in the usual manner.
I am at the conclusion of my presentation. [ believe I have made it as objective as could be expected of a man who has been suddenly thrown out of his position and apparently also out of his profession. I will not speak here of the indescribable injustice that has been committed against me personally; of the fact that they heard me with my conviction already prepared in their pockets; that after my suspension they found nothing more pressing to do than to inform the director of it, although the matter did not at all concern him, since it had not been he that had brought the information to the community; of the fact that the most important means for my defense, the director’s note, was denied me; that the representatives convicted me without having heard me; and, finally, that this affair which should have been finished in one night, since it concerned not only the material subsistence, but also the honor and reputation of a man, was allowed to drag its course for three months. All this may be dismissed to-day since it affects me personally. This affair has for me, however, a kernel that lies deeper. I have been condemned because of my beliefs and they are beliefs that I still cherish to-day. And I demand that public opinion concern itself with these beliefs. Ay, it must and it will busy itself with the question whether a rabbi may express views, as I have done, or will he by so doing “show himself unworthy of the respect, the reverence and the trust which his oflice requires” And it will have to pass judgment whether it is really true that the expression of such views endangers Judaism and the rights of those who profess it.