The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 6 · June 1907
218printed page
scan 18 of 54

worth to their nationality, it actually lives. There would be no anti-Semitism were it otherwise. We are not hated because we are worse, but because we are different, that is, racially distinguishable. I can, therefore, understand the aversion against us as a certain reaction even though I oppose anti-Semitism itself most earnestly and condemn it in ts various forms as immoral. This aversion will remain as long as we Jews do not give up our racial distinctiveness.. We are not even thinking of doing so, as is shown by the fact that even in circles where no great value is set on our race, intermarriage is rejected. The race instinct is very strong. This is shown by the deep affection that binds us to our eastern brethren of the same race, although spiritually and culturally they are separated from us by the width of the heavens. The poor Russian Jews must be closer to my heart now than the Christians of my German iatherland, because beside us Jews, there is no one to take pity on these unfortunates. No Christian took their part during the recent persecutions. There are, it is true, Jews who deny this racial sympathy. They are either lost in illusions or seek in ungrounded fear to confuse the condition of affaırs.

The director appeared to be astounded at these affırmations. “I have a Jewish head teacher. According to this, I cannot trust him any longer when he assures me he is a good German citizen. I suppose I must consider him a hypocrite?”

“Not at all,” I answered. “I regard my-. self as an excellent German citizen; I love German culture beyond everything; I cannot and will not eliminate Goethe and Schiller from my soul. In spite of that I cherish my Jewish racial individuality which goes well together with German citizenship.”

The director did not think this true. He believed we should thus create a state within a state. I replied that good citizenship was independent of racial allegiance. He rejected this also. School and education required the nurture of only one kind of raciality, the German. I was in duty bound in my religious instruction to raise up the children to be German-national men. I replied that I should, as always, impress on their hearts the duty of

inmost love and loyalty to state and fatherland. That was the Jewish commandment. The spread of German-national ideas, however, was the special business of the teachers of history.

This, in very brief outline, is the essence of the more than three hours' conversation. It was private, as the Herr Director himself later in certain circles himself admitted and proceeded in the most friendly manner.

II. THE PROVISIONAL SUSPENSION.

On January 31, I was summoned to an interview at the Jewish communal office. I went there unsuspectingly. I found the president, Herr Julius Jacoby, and the syndic Lilienthal present. They demanded excitedly that I explain my conversation with the director. I hesitated, since it had been private. A statement of the director's was laid before me, which he was supposed to have written in his official journal. The conversation, accordingly, had been official.

This writing was not, despite repeated requests on my part, given to me. Hence I am obliged to quote from memory. In its main points my quotation is surely correct:

“Herr Dr. Cohn declares that according to his opinion every Jew is obliged to feel that he is a member of God’s chosen people, from whom he yet expects great things in the future. As such he must feel greater sympathy with his poor Russian brother than with a German Christian and must reject complete assimilation. Whosoever thinks differently lies, consciously or unconsciously. Herr Dr. Cohn considers complete assimilation to be impossible. He sees in Zionism the only solution of the Jewish question. He is able to understand anti-Semitism as a natural reaction.”

As these words were presented to me I £elt it my duty to express myself further. My first words were: “This have I said, and yet not said.” I said it, in so far as I recognize the thoughts round which the director’s sentences center and I see no reason for denying it. But I never said it in that form nor with such crassnes. The expression concerning the lying of those who think differently never crossed my lips.. Much that I emphasized has been left unexpressed in the writing and vice versa. These lines are an arbitrary extract